‘Philosophy Is Thinking Outside the Box’
In October 2024, Louis Vervoort, Associate Professor at the School of Philosophy and Cultural Studies of the Faculty of Humanities presented his report ‘Gettier's Problem and Quine's Epistemic Holism: A Unified Account’ at the Formal Philosophy seminar, which covered one of the basic problems of contemporary epistemology. What are the limitations of physics as a science? What are the dangers of AI? How to survive the Russian cold? Louis Vervoort discussed these and many other questions in his interview with the HSE News Service.
Before obtaining a PhD in the philosophy of science, Louis Vervoort completed a PhD in physics (Université de Marseille) and a postdoctoral fellowship in physics at École Normale Supérieure in Paris. This combination of experience in both philosophy and physics naturally led him to focus his interests on the philosophy of physics and artificial intelligence, and more classical topics such as epistemology and the philosophy of mind, free will and consciousness.
Louis Vervoort
—Let's start with your arrival to Russia in Tyumen. What interested you in coming there? What did you teach? How did you survive Siberian cold weather?
—In Tyumen, I started my first job as a professor, thanks to a new English-speaking interdisciplinary teaching and research centre that was created there in 2017. With my atypical CV in physics and philosophy, I was happy to find a position so soon after my post-doc in Montreal. I taught a variety of courses, mostly in philosophy (of science, of physics, of AI).
Siberia attracted me from the start, I suppose because I have a certain taste for adventure.
It is a great place for discovering all kinds of things unseen in the West, such as its nature, local people and communities, cities, food, and habits.
Getting used to the climate is quite easy with regular physical outdoor activities
Tyumen actually gets much more sun than Western Europe, where I originally come from, and don’t forget: I came from Canada, where snow is even more abundant.
—You have a unique background with a PhD in philosophy of science and a PhD in physics. What are the top philosophical problems of modern physics?
—In my opinion, the top philosophical problem of modern physics is the understanding of quantum mechanics. Quantum theory is very efficient for calculating and predicting the outcomes of experiments on atomic systems. But, at the same time, it is often said that nobody really understands the theory—what it means beyond the mathematics.
Physicists often are happy to ‘just calculate and do experiments,’ but I believe this approach has clearly shown its limitations
Physics has been at an impasse for decades: quantum theory is in contradiction with the other pillar of physics, general relativity theory, and efforts to unify both theories are still not working, even after half a century of research.
I believe that new ideas are necessary, and that philosophy can help: philosophy is thinking outside the box.
Also, philosophers can elucidate some of the flabbergasting features of quantum theory, such as non-locality (do particles feel each other instantaneously over infinite distances?), the Schroedinger cat paradox, quantum teleportation, etc. Interestingly enough, some of these problems—which all are at the interface of physics and philosophy—have links with well-known philosophical theories.
—What are the most critical philosophical issues in AI? What are the potential risks of widespread AI distribution?
—Personally, I believe that the most interesting question in the foundations of AI is whether there is a difference between artificial and natural thinking. Does a key rational skill exist in humans, which—perhaps—cannot be emulated by AI? Or can this skill be taught to AI?
In general, I am not pessimistic in regards to the future use of AI, as long as benevolent humans, having a sense of the ethical issues raised by AI, keep control over it
To me, the largest risk is that AI can, in principle, give a sudden and critical cognitive advantage to a small group of people, who may or may not have intentions beneficial for everyone. So, once again, the risk is about creating unacceptable inequalities among people—which can, and should, be mitigated by governments by imposing rules on the use and creation of AI.
All in all, I am moderately optimistic: AI has enormous potential, which could be used to improve society on many levels
Ah, and I almost forgot: another risk is that we, teachers, will be replaced by AI at some point, but I hope that decision makers will understand that there is a decisive psychological factor to take into account: I suspect that students always will find benefits in interacting with real teachers!
—How is AI being researched by you and other HSE experts? What are your conclusions so far?
—One of my conclusions is that, for the time being, we still have one critical advantage over AI, but it is difficult to predict how long we can hold onto it. A year? Ten years? A bit longer? I call this key skill ‘hypothetical-deductive’ thinking, the core ingredient of scientific thinking.
It would be particularly interesting to study if AI and artificial neural nets can improve at this kind of reasoning together with computer science colleagues (of course, sometimes AI already comes close, but not yet in complex situations). I hope to achieve this at HSE, but it hasn’t happened yet. In the meanwhile, there are many experts in AI at HSE in the computer science department and several other departments. Unfortunately, it is difficult to get in touch with them, for example, because the different departments are located on different campuses.
—You've presented a research paper at the HSE Formal Philosophy seminar. What's next in your research pipeline?
—I am working on the questions of quantum physics and AI that I previously mentioned. Another topic is free will and consciousness, which I would like to study with neuroscientists.
—You speak many languages, including English, French, German, Italian, Dutch, Spanish. I can't help but ask about your Russian after so many years here.
—Touché. Well, my Russian is good enough for superficial conversations, but unfortunately not for academic discussions. All my students, colleagues and friends are excellent in English or French. The best way for me to learn Russian better would be to teach a course in Russian. I am working on it!
—You've been at HSE University for two years already. How are things going for you while working and living in Moscow? What are your goals and challenges?
—Living in such a megalopolis as Moscow comes with its challenges, such as transport and expensive housing, but I have to say that Moscow has the best public transport of all the big cities I know. It’s amazing how fast one can travel within the city, and at an affordable price.
Moscow has an enormous intellectual capital
But one thing I have not yet managed is to become a part of a vibrant community of people who would like to do common interdisciplinary research. Maybe this is an idea for the future: creating a platform at HSE University for facilitating interdisciplinary research.
See also:
HSE & VK Engineering and Mathematics School Showcases 13 Projects at 10th Demo Day
The 10th Demo Day of the Joint HSE & VK Engineering and Mathematics School was held at the VK Moscow office. Students of the three workshops presented the results of 13 projects in the fields of artificial intelligence, information security, and digital platforms. Students worked on the development of recommendation services, systems for psycholinguistic text analysis and speech processing, methods for identifying celebrities in videos, algorithms for determining the toxicity of memes, security mechanisms for AI systems, and approaches to improving the effectiveness of neural network models.
Tabular Data Anonymisation Solution for Safe Use in AI Systems Developed at HSE University
The AI and Digital Science Institute at the HSE Faculty of Computer Science has developed a tabular data anonymisation service designed to prepare corporate datasets for use in analytics and AI applications. The solution can identify personal data in structured datasets, apply consistent and reproducible anonymisation rules, and generate the artifacts required for quality control, auditing, and subsequent use of data in secure environments.
HSE Scientists Develop Method to Compress Large Language Models Without Losing Quality
Researchers from the AI and Digital Science Institute at the HSE Faculty of Computer Science have developed a new compression method for large language models such as GPT and LLaMA that reduces their size by 25–36% without additional training or significant loss of accuracy. This is the first approach to use mathematical transformations—specifically, rotations of model weights—to make models more amenable to compression with structured matrices. The study results have been published in ACL Findings 2025. The code is available on GitHub.
HSE Scientists Train Neural Network to 'Hear' Faults in Electric Motors
Researchers at the AI and Digital Science Institute of the HSE Faculty of Computer Science have developed a new method—the Signature-Guided Data Augmentation (SGDA) framework—that achieves 99% accuracy in motor fault detection and 86% accuracy in fault classification. The application of this approach can reduce industrial equipment repair costs, minimise downtime, and improve production safety. The study results have been published in Engineering Applications of Artificial Intelligence.
HSE Graduate’s AI Project Wins at TECH & AI Awards
Daria Davydova, graduate of the HSE Graduate School of Business and Head of the AI Implementation Unit at the Artificial Intelligence Department of Alfa-Bank, received a prize at the TECH & AI Awards. She was awarded for the best AI solution for optimising business processes. The winners were determined as part of the VII Russian Summit and Awards on Digital Transformation (CDO/CDTO Summit & Awards).
New Neural Network for Science and Innovation Being Developed at HSE University
HSE researchers are training large language models (LLMs) to understand Russian-language scientific terminology while improving their energy efficiency. The adapted model runs 2.7 times faster and requires 73% less memory than the original open model, allowing it to operate on more affordable hardware. The programme has passed state registration.
HSE FCS Researchers Showcase AI and Bioinformatics Breakthroughs at ICLR 2026
Researchers from the AI and Digital Science Institute at the HSE Faculty of Computer Science, along with students from the AI360: Artificial Intelligence Engineering track of the Applied Mathematics and Information Science bachelor’s programme, took part in ICLR, one of the world’s most prestigious international conferences on machine learning and representation learning. This year’s event was held in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.
The Future of Cardiogenetics Lies in Artificial Intelligence
Researchers from the AI and Digital Science Institute at the HSE Faculty of Computer Science have developed a program capable of analysing regions of the human genome that were previously inaccessible for accurate interpretation in genetic testing. The program adapts large generative AI (GenAI) models for cardiogenetics to predict how specific mutations affect the function of individual genes.
HSE and Yandex Propose Method to Speed Up Neural Networks for Image Generation
A team of scientists at HSE FCS and Yandex Research has proposed a method that reduces computational costs and accelerates text-to-image generation in diffusion models without compromising quality. These models currently set the standard for text-to-image generation, but their use is limited by high computational loads, the company said in a statement.
A Trap for the Advanced Student: How to Break the Habit of Blindly Trusting Neural Networks
Andrei Ternikov, Associate Professor at the St Petersburg School of Economics and Management at HSE University–St Petersburg, has developed a method for conducting online exams that significantly limits students’ ability to use ChatGPT and other AI models to obtain correct answers. Andrei Ternikov spoke to the HSE News Service about his approach—which won the HSE University Autumn Educational Innovation Competition, received an Alfa Future grant, and was presented at an international conference in Japan.