Researchers Uncover Specific Aspects of Story Comprehension in Young Children
For the first time, psycholinguists from the HSE Centre for Language and Brain, in collaboration with colleagues from the USA and Germany, recorded eye movements during a test to assess narrative skills in young children and adults. The researchers found that story comprehension depends on plot structure, and that children aged five to six tend to struggle with questions about protagonists' internal states. The study findings have been published in the Journal of Experimental Child Psychology.
The ability to perceive and produce coherent stories, also known as narrative skills, marks an important stage in the development of children's language and cognitive functions. Research shows that story comprehension develops in several stages, progressing from the simple perception of event sequences to the ability to interpret protagonists' actions and internal states, such as their thoughts, emotions, and intentions.
Specialised tests are employed to assess narrative skills. One of the most widely used tools for evaluating the narrative abilities of multilingual children is the Multilingual Assessment Instrument for Narratives (MAIN). It includes four animal stories—Cat, Dog, Baby Goats, and Baby Birds—each told through a sequence of six pictures. The child's task is to produce a story based on pictures and answer ten questions about each story. The questions address the motives behind the protagonists' actions (such as ‘Why did the dog jump up the tree?’) as well as their internal states (eg ‘How does the dog feel?’)
Although the stories are similar in structural and visual complexity, some studies, in particular, those by researchers at Uppsala University—have shown that the Cat and Dog stories (Figure 1) may be easier for children to process than the Baby Goats and Baby Birds stories (Figure 2). One possible explanation is that children may find it particularly challenging to answer questions about the internal states of the story's protagonists, compared to questions about their motivations and goals. In a new study, researchers from the Centre for Language and Brain at HSE University, in collaboration with colleagues from the USA and Germany, tested this hypothesis and also investigated whether visual cues would make it easier for children to respond to questions about the protagonists' internal states.
The researchers conducted two experiments: one with 53 children aged five and six as the experimental group, and another with 20 young adults as the control group. Participants viewed the stories on a computer screen and answered questions about the protagonists' motives and internal states. In some cases, visual cues were provided, such as a circle drawn around a protagonist to attract attention to their facial expression. During the experiment, eye-tracking technology was used to record participants' eye movements, helping identify which elements of the story took them longer to process. The authors analysed the accuracy of responses to comprehension questions based on the story, the type of question, and the presence of a visual cue.
Although adults generally performed better on the test than children, the Baby Birds and Baby Goats stories were more difficult for all participants to comprehend compared to the Cat and Dog stories. This may be due to the number of protagonists and the plot structure: both the Cat and Dog stories feature fewer protagonists, with the pictures more clearly indicating their motives—eg the dog is hungry and wants to grab sausages from the boy’s bag. In contrast, the Baby Goats and Baby Birds stories involve more protagonists, whose motives may be less obvious, such as why the dog chases the cat away. In general, children performed worse on questions about the protagonists' internal states—for instance, how the dog felt when the mouse ran away in Picture 1—compared to questions about their goals, such as what they intended to do and why, like why the dog grabbed the sausages. Visual cues, while they helped draw attention to the details of the stories, did not improve the children’s ability to interpret the protagonists' emotions.
The study contributes to understanding the mechanisms underlying story perception in children and may be useful in developing new diagnostic methods for language disorders.
Vladislava Staroverova
'Our findings suggest that at the age of five or six, children lack sufficient cognitive experience to assess the internal states of protagonists in the pictures and find it more challenging to interpret the protagonists' internal world than their motives for actions. This knowledge can contribute to the development of programmes aimed at enhancing language skills and emotional intelligence,' explains Vladislava Staroverova, Junior Research Fellow at the Centre for Language and Brain and co-author of the study.
See also:
The 'Second Shift' Is Not Why Women Avoid News
Women are more likely than men to avoid political and economic news, but the reasons for this behaviour are linked less to structural inequality or family-related stress than to personal attitudes and the emotional perception of news content. This conclusion was reached by HSE researchers after analysing data from a large-scale survey of more than 10,000 residents across 61 regions of Russia. The study findings have been published in Woman in Russian Society.
Preserving Rationality in a Period of Turbulence
The HSE International Laboratory for Logic, Linguistics and Formal Philosophy studies logic and rationality in a transformed world characterised by a diversity of logical systems and rational agents. The laboratory supports and develops academic ties with Russian and international partners. The HSE News Service spoke with the head of the laboratory, Prof. Elena Dragalina-Chernaya, about its work.
Resource Race and Green Transition: Three Unexpected Conclusions from Foresight Centre’s Research on Climate and Poverty
Beneath the surface of green energy—which most people associate with solar panels, electric vehicles, and reduced CO2 emissions—lies a complex web of geopolitical interests, international inequality, and resource constraints. Researchers from the Laboratory for Science and Technology Studies (LST) at the HSE ISSEK Foresight Centre have published a series of articles in leading international journals on hidden and overt conflicts surrounding critically important metals and minerals, as well as related processes in the energy sector.
Immersion in Second Language Environment Influences Bilinguals’ Perception of Emotions
Researchers at the Cognitive Health and Intelligence Centre at the HSE Institute for Cognitive Neuroscience have discovered how bilingual individuals process emotional words in their native (first) and non-native (second) languages. It was found that the link between word meaning and bodily sensations is weaker in a second language than in a first language. However, the more a person is immersed in a language environment, the smaller this difference becomes. The article has been published in Language, Cognition and Neuroscience.
‘Any Real-Economy Company Can Use Our Products’
The HSE Centre for Financial Research and Data Analytics combines fundamental and applied work, including in areas unique to Russia such as the connection between sentiment in the media and social networks and financial markets. The HSE News Service spoke with the centre’s director, Professor Tamara Teplova, about its work.
Researchers Find More Effective Approach to Revealing Majorana Zero Modes in Superconductors
An international team of researchers, including physicists from HSE MIEM, has demonstrated that nonmagnetic impurities can help more accurately reveal Majorana zero modes—quantum states considered promising building blocks for quantum computing. The researchers found that these impurities shift the energy levels that typically obscure the Majorana signal, while leaving the mode itself largely unaffected, thereby making its spectral peak more distinct. The study has been published in Research.
New Development by HSE Scientists Helps Design Reliable Electronics Faster at a Lower Cost
Scientists from HSE MIEM have developed a new approach to modelling electrothermal processes in high-power electronic circuits on printed circuit boards (PCB). The method allows engineers to quickly and accurately predict how electronic components heat up during operation, helping prevent overheating and potential failures. The results have been published in Russian Microelectronics.
The Future of Cardiogenetics Lies in Artificial Intelligence
Researchers from the AI and Digital Science Institute at the HSE Faculty of Computer Science have developed a program capable of analysing regions of the human genome that were previously inaccessible for accurate interpretation in genetic testing. The program adapts large generative AI (GenAI) models for cardiogenetics to predict how specific mutations affect the function of individual genes.
'Where Accurate Prediction of the Outcome Is Impossible, Stochastic Methods Come into Play'
The Laboratory of Stochastic Analysis and its Applications at HSE University studies systems and events in which randomness plays a central role. The goal is to predict various phenomena and how they evolve over time. The HSE News Service interviewed the laboratory's head Vladimir Panov and its academic supervisor Valentin Konakov.
HSE Researchers: Young Russians Have Sufficient Knowledge About Money but Lack Money Management Skills
Adolescents and young adults in Russia today are well versed in financial terminology: they know what bank cards, loans, interest rates, and online payments are. However, as researchers at HSE University have found, real money-management skills remain poorly developed among most young people. The study ‘Financial Literacy, Financial Culture, and Financial Autonomy of Youth’ has been published in Monitoring of Public Opinion: Economic and Social Changes.