Two Years of Growth or Decline: How to Choose an Investment Strategy
Economists from HSE University, together with colleagues from international universities, have analysed stock market movements over almost a century and proposed an investment strategy that could have delivered returns nearly twice as high as the market average. Their research suggests following a momentum strategy during periods of sustained market growth and switching to a value strategy after prolonged market declines. The study has been published in the Journal of Banking and Finance.
Two main investment strategies dominate equity markets. The momentum strategy involves buying stocks that have recently performed well and selling those that have underperformed. The value strategy takes the opposite approach, purchasing relatively undervalued stocks while selling more expensive ones. Momentum tends to perform well during rising markets, whereas value investing generates stronger returns when investors shift their attention towards cheaper stocks. Investors may choose either strategy or combine the two in different proportions.
Following the global financial crisis of 2008, many investors concluded that value investing had lost its effectiveness. Undervalued stocks no longer consistently outperformed expensive ones, and the strategy popularised by Warren Buffett—which helped him build a fortune estimated at around $150 billion—appeared to have fallen out of favour.
However, Victoria Dobrynskaya, Assistant Professor at the HSE Faculty of Economic Sciences, together with her international co-authors, demonstrates that the value strategy remains highly profitable. According to the researchers, it performs well only under specific market conditions that have been largely absent in recent years.
The authors interpret their findings through the lens of behavioural finance. During prolonged market rallies, investor optimism can lead to the overvaluation of some companies and the undervaluation of others. When markets decline, optimism fades, allowing prices to return more quickly to levels that reflect companies' fundamental value. The researchers describe this sharp correction as a ‘value boom.’
The study examined the price movements of all stocks listed on the New York Stock Exchange and NASDAQ between 1926 and 2022. This period includes the Great Depression, the 1973 oil crisis, the dot-com crash and the 2008 global financial crisis. The researchers then repeated the analysis using stock market data from 20 developed economies.
Previous research assumed that returns from value investing were distributed relatively evenly over long investment horizons and that temporary losses would eventually be offset by future gains. However, the new study shows that almost all profits from the value strategy are generated during relatively rare value booms. The researchers identified 38 such episodes over nearly 100 years of observations. One striking example occurred in August 1932, as markets emerged from the Great Depression: the value strategy returned 68% in a single month after the market had lost around two-thirds of its value over the preceding two years.
Similar value booms were observed across the other 20 developed markets included in the study. Although the average annual return of the value strategy in these countries was 3.6%, it increased to 8.6% following significant declines in local stock markets.
Based on these findings, the researchers propose a new investment approach: investors should follow a momentum strategy when the market has risen over the previous two years and switch to a value strategy after a two-year market decline. Historically, this switching strategy would have generated annual returns of 18.5%, compared with 13.7% for a pure momentum strategy, 5.0% for a pure value strategy, and 9.6% for conventional blended strategies.
Victoria Dobrynskaya
‘This switching strategy could also work in the Russian stock market. However, the Russian market moves more rapidly, so the optimal time horizon for switching may differ from two years. In addition, there are relatively few listed companies in Russia from which an appropriate portfolio can be constructed, which could reduce potential returns. This is an issue that requires separate research,’ said Victoria Dobrynskaya, Assistant Professor at the HSE Faculty of Economic Sciences.
See also:
‘The Peak of Stupidity’ and ‘The Valley of Despair’: HSE Economists Propose an Explanation for the Dunning–Kruger Effect
The Dunning–Kruger effect, which describes a sharp surge in self-confidence among beginners followed by an equally rapid decline as they gain experience, can be explained by the nature of the learning process and the acquisition of new knowledge. This conclusion was reached by Andrey Vorchik of the HSE Faculty of Economic Sciences together with independent researcher Murat Mamyshev. They developed a mathematical model of learning and demonstrated how subjective confidence is formed and changes as knowledge accumulates, as well as how teachers can reduce the ‘valley of despair’ experienced by learners.
Toffee and Risk: Scientists Discover Why People Who Crave Sweets Make More Impulsive Choices
Having a sweet tooth may be linked not only to eating habits but also to the way people make decisions. Researchers at HSE University have found that people with a preference for sweet foods tend to behave more impulsively—not because they want immediate rewards, but because they are less willing to tolerate uncertainty. These findings may help improve treatments for addiction. The study findings have been published in Frontiers in Psychology.
Physicists Find a Way to Model Ion Parameters in Plasma in Seconds
Researchers from HSE University and the Moscow Institute of Physics and Technology (MIPT) have developed a set of simple analytical methods for calculating the properties of heavy ions in helium under the influence of a strong electric field. The new approach speeds up calculations of ion mobility and ion–molecule reaction rates by thousands of times while maintaining sufficient accuracy for plasma jet modelling. The findings have been published in the journal Physica Scripta.
Researchers Reveal Link Between Attention and Communication Difficulties in Autism
Researchers at HSE University have examined how communication difficulties in children with autism are related to brain function. The findings show that not only language networks but also attention networks play an important role. The weaker the connections involved in maintaining focus and switching attention, the more pronounced communication difficulties were. The study has been published in European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry.
Scientists Discover Why Some People Wore Masks During COVID-19 While Others Did Not
Why do some people voluntarily follow new rules while others ignore them? Researchers at HSE University have found that the answer lies not so much in people's willingness to cooperate, as previously believed, but in their ability to empathise with others. Empathy proved to be the strongest predictor of whether people chose to wear face masks voluntarily during the COVID-19 pandemic. The findings have been published in Frontiers.
Physicists at HSE University and FIAN Discover Way to 'Photograph' Sound for Testing Materials Used in 6G Communications
Researchers at HSE University, in collaboration with colleagues from the Lebedev Physical Institute of the Russian Academy of Sciences (FIAN), have developed a method for rapidly determining how firmly a film is bonded to a substrate. This is important for the creation of ultrahigh-frequency acoustic filters, which are key components of next-generation 5G and 6G communications. For the first time, researchers have succeeded in measuring the lateral rigidity of the bond between a two-dimensional material film and a substrate in this way. The study results have been published in Applied Physics Letters.
Scientists Create Open Dataset for Studying Concentration
A team of Russian researchers, including scientists from HSE University–St Petersburg, has developed the first open multimodal dataset containing recordings of brain activity, heart function, and video observations to help researchers understand what happens in the human brain during deep concentration. In the future, the dataset could accelerate the development of neural interfaces, rehabilitation technologies, and AI systems. The article has been published in Scientific Data.
Scientists Propose Method for More Efficient Resource Use in Machine Learning
An international group of researchers, including mathematicians from the AI and Digital Science Institute at the HSE Faculty of Computer Science, has provided a theoretical justification for a simple and computationally efficient method of estimating uncertainty in Stochastic Gradient Descent (SGD). The paper has been published on the scientific preprint server arXiv.org and presented at AISTATS 2026.
Team Success: Aligning Means with Objectives
In corporations, sports, and academia, people often face challenges they cannot handle alone. In such cases, selecting the right team is crucial. Tatiana Mayskaya, Associate Professor at the HSE Faculty of Economic Sciences and the International College of Economics and Finance, together with colleagues from foreign universities, examined team characteristics and found that less diverse teams are better suited to objectives where a high average performance is important, whereas more diverse teams are preferable when avoiding failure is critical. The paper has been published in Economic Theory.
Economists Propose More Effective Approach to Reducing Smoking
Economists at HSE University have examined how smokers respond to changes in cigarette prices. When tobacco prices increase, cigarette consumption does not always decline. In fact, spending on tobacco may even rise: according to the researchers, a 1% decrease in cigarette affordability leads to a 0.28% increase in per capita tobacco expenditure. The findings suggest that to reduce smoking rates, tobacco prices must rise faster than household incomes. The study has been published in Voprosy Statistiki.