• A
  • A
  • A
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
Regular version of the site

Russian IT Freelancers Face Gender Discrimination

Russian IT Freelancers Face Gender Discrimination

Olga Vilkova, a PhD student of the HSE University's Faculty of Social Sciences, has proved that IT engineers face inequality and discrimination on the Russian online freelance market—websites offering jobs for self-employed people. The researcher analyzed the data on professional success of 54,000 IT engineers registered on the major Russian freelancing platform FL.ru. The research is published in the Monitoring of Public Opinion: Economic and Social Changes Journal..

The research is based on Igor Kon’s sociological approach with a focus on the ‘environment that causes prejudices’ (online freelancing platforms) and not the bearer of the prejudices (the customer).

A parser was used to collect data from FL.ru. The data were extracted using web scraping—process of collecting open data from webpages and other sources. The researcher received information on social and demographic characteristics of IT freelancers registered on FL.ru from 2005 to 2019 as well as information on their performance on the platform and the projects they completed indicating the cost of their services. In addition to that, 20 in-depth online interviews were conducted with female engineers using FL.ru as the main source of jobs.

Finally, 54,000 freelancers were grouped into 33 areas: web-development (68.1% of the total profiles analyzed), web-programming (32.6 %), web-design (15.3 %), ‘turnkey’ website development (11.9 %), etc.

Female engineers are engaged in 17 out of 33 areas only, most frequently in web-programming, ‘turnkey’ website development, web-design, designing and supporting online stores, and testing websites and apps for Android.

‘Although women and men implement projects nearly identical in terms of time consumption and complexity, status of female engineers on freelancing platforms is lower,’ says Olga Vilkova.

Customers are less likely to spot a women as a potential contractor, which leads to female engineers ranking lower in the organic search results, except for web design projects and Flash-/Flex-programming. As for the latter technology, however, men are not too willing to deal with it, as it is getting more and more obsolete these days.

Female profiles appear to be visited less frequently: by 49% as far as the total 33 areas is concerned and by 8% in the areas of female presence.

Women are contracted 43% less frequently than men.

The total freelance rating is 69% higher for men in all professional areas, and 19% higher in the areas of female presence.

Men usually receive 52% more money for their projects in total (RUB 5,112 for men vs. RUB 2,428 for women) and 0.6% more money for the projects in the areas of female freelancers’ presence. (RUB 2,500 vs. RUB 2,485).

The average annual income of men is 83% and 65% higher, depending on the area analyzed.

Women receive higher remuneration on average in six areas (out of 14, in which the researcher was able to find out the cost of work): by 33% in Content Management System administration; by 26% in developing flash websites; by 14% in QA-testing; by 12% in web designing; by 10% in 1С-programming; and by 4% in creating online stores.

Even so, the most expensive projects usually go to men. Most lucrative projects are related to system programming (an average of RUB 48,000 per project) and databases (RUB 20,000), but there are no bids from female engineers in these areas on FL.ru.

Customers more often give reviews about the projects performed by male IT specialists—there are 20 reviews on average per female engineer compared to 25 reviews per their male counterpart. Given that woman work in fewer number of areas, ‘the attention is approximately similar’, man receive a little more positive reviews than women, and the share of female IT specialists with 100% positive feedback is even bigger: 71.4% vs. 69.2%.

Few people believe that gender discrimination in freelance is impossible and it does not matter whether a man or a woman is doing the job as long as the quality is adequate. The majority of the respondents though conclude that discrimination does exist, and prejudices are still alive and get in the way immediately, once the customer begins selecting the potential contractor

See also:

Helping Others Improves the Lives and Psychological Well-being of Russians

HSE Researcher Ekaterina Nastina has found that the more often Russians help others (whether loved ones or strangers), the more satisfied they are with their lives. However, if a person is over 50 years of age or if values of social justice are important to him or her, helping family and friends has no significant influence on his or her psychological well-being. On the other hand, pro-social, altruistic behaviour towards strangers is equally beneficial to people of all ages and beliefs. A total of 757 respondents took part in the study. An article containing the results was published in the Sociological Journal.

Incompatible Alternatives: HSE Researchers on the Ambivalence of Power in the Twenty-first Century Economy

Ambivalence and a combination of contradictory principles are vividly manifested in the actions of government, its individual agents and institutions, as well as the everyday practices of economic subjects and citizens. The participants of the HSE Laboratory for Studies in Economic Sociology seminar discussed the book The Ambivalence of Power in the Twenty-First Century Economy: Cases from Russia and Beyond, recently published in the UK. Prepared by researchers from HSE University and foreign universities, the book focuses on the study of ambivalence in Russia and beyond.

People Are Reluctant to See Anthropomorphic Robot Assistants

Researchers from HSE University studied the perception of social robots (robots that are able to communicate with people and assist them with various needs) in everyday situations. They studied the perception of such factors as the robots’ appearance, speech, interaction situations, as well as the respondents’ characteristics. The scholars found that androids are more desirable in various situations than humanoids (robots that only vaguely resemble humans).

Satanism, According to Science: How Sociology Explains the Worship of Dark Forces

The concept of Satanism originating from Roman Catholic sources continues to lack a rigorous social science interpretation. Satanism is sometimes believed to be a reflection of real-life problems faced by society and is sometimes considered a phenomenon in its own right that merits serious study. HSE doctoral student Oxana Mikhailova provides an overview of how the concept of Satanism is treated by different sociological theories and offers her commentary.

HSE Researcher Reveals Work Values Held by New Generation of Undergraduates

A large-scale study carried out by Anita Poplavskaya, postgraduate student at the HSE Faculty of Social Sciences’ Department of Economic Sociology, on a sample of 5,000 undergraduates at eight regional universities in Russia reveals the students' prevalent work values. The top five include high pay, interest in one's work, job security, skills match, and career prospects. 

'We Construct a Portrait of Russian Society'

HSE is presenting A Society of Unequal Opportunities: The Social Structure of Modern Russia, a new book whose authors use an original model to paint a collective portrait of Russians in the last decade. IQ.HSE asked Svetlana Mareeva, co-author of the monograph and Director of the HSE Institute of Social Policy’s Centre for Stratification Studies, about the highlights and trends discussed in the book and whether they tend to change in particularly challenging times.

Media Portraits of High-Achieving Women

Women who have made it to the top in business often look back to analyse what has helped — or hindered — their advancement in this highly gendered environment. Shared through mass media, their reflections can provide helpful guidance to other aspiring businesswomen on what it takes to succeed. HSE sociologists have examined relevant media discourse and identified ten key factors of women's business leadership.

No Head in the Clouds: Survey Results Refute Stereotypes of Young People

In the run-up to Youth Day, IQ.HSE studied the results of an all-Russian survey by the Centre for Studies of Civil Society and the Nonprofit Sector. Sociologists studied the role of young people in charity and volunteering. What do they sacrifice for the sake of their neighbours — and are they prepared to do it in general? For those who think that young people have their heads in the clouds, the answers will be unexpected.

Returning to Life: How to Help 'Troubled' Teens Get a Fresh Start and Integrate into Society

Some children who don’t go to school and commit crimes manage to reintegrate into society by learning new mores and lifestyles. But others only appear to adapt, becoming ‘outsiders’ again the minute they leave the school grounds, going back to the same risky life on the streets. The two approaches offer youngsters very different opportunities in life. This IQ.HSE article, that draws on research by sociologist Irina Lisovskaya, explores how to help such youth integrate into society and learn to communicate with others.

Discussing ‘The Chair’ in the Context of Contemporary University Problems

At the end of December 2021, the Laboratory for Studies in Economic Sociology (LSES) at HSE University held its traditional Christmas Cinema Seminar entitled ‘Where are universities going?’ Participants discussed ‘The Chair’, a TV series created by David Benioff and Daniel Brett Weiss, authors of ‘Game of Thrones’. 2021 marked the 20th anniversary of the Christmas seminar, which LSES has held to discuss hot-button issues after watching famous Russian and foreign films.