• A
  • A
  • A
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
Regular version of the site

Researchers Confirm Correlation Between Education Expenditure and GDP Growth

Researchers Confirm Correlation Between Education Expenditure and GDP Growth

© Daniil Prokofyev / HSE University

HSE University researchers have analyzed the economic performance of almost a hundred countries to understand whether government investment in education pays off. The economists explain what kind of recommendations may be offered to governments—and how they vary based on a country's level of development—in the Voprosy Statistiki journal.

Countries with a larger proportion of educated people have higher-quality human capital and labour productivity, more successful rollout of new technologies, and more efficient policies to prevent poverty, unemployment and crime. Education is expected to improve the income of individuals and the organizations where they work, contributing to GDP growth as a result.­ However, empirical studies do not always validate this hypothesis. Using a large volume of data, HSE University researchers decided to verify whether education expenditure is justified in the short and long term.

The economists used World Bank data for 32 developed member nations of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (including the United States, the United Kingdom, Germany, Japan, and Australia) and 59 developing non-members (including Russia, Argentina, and India). Details of GDP per capita, government spending on education (overall and by individual stage), the share of economically active citizens, and gross investment in the economy were available for 1995–2018. The economists also applied mathematical models to verify the degree of correlation between national GDP and education expenditure (a proxy measure of human capital in this case).

The calculations revealed a positive correlation between GDP and expenditure at all educational stages for the first group of countries (OECD members). The correlation is stronger over the long term (five to ten years) for secondary and professional education expenditure. The economists believe that this correlation also operates in reverse—governments invest in education because they are wealthy and can afford to, but the effect of these investments on GDP can also be monitored with a 5–10 year delay. Primary education expenditure has the smallest effect. This can be explained by the fact that in developed economies, almost the entire population has a primary education. The return on such investment is low because modern labour markets require increasingly complex knowledge and skills.

The relationship between GDP and education expenditure is minimal in countries of the second group in the short term. A material (and positive) delayed effect can only be seen in the case of expenditure on primary education. The relationship observed between GDP and expenditure on secondary and professional education is negative— in developing economies, increased investment in these stages has not yet borne fruit, and contributes to GDP growth deceleration. This occurs in countries where people can get a university degree, but there are not enough corresponding jobs. Those with specialized education often leave for more developed countries, meaning that education expenditure does not stimulate economic growth.

The study shows that there is a relationship between education expenditure and economic growth, but its manifestations depend on the nation’s level of development.

Marina Kolosnitsyna, Professor at the Faculty of Economic Sciences, co-author of the study

'It should, of course, be understood that countries differ by GDP and investment in education both within the OECD and outside the organization. The conclusions are therefore more likely to apply to an ‘average’ country in each group, but not necessarily to each of them to the same extent. Russia is obviously not an average country in the second group. It is comparable to less-developed countries in the OECD group in terms of GDP, and even outpaces many of them by level of education.'

The authors of the study emphasize that although education expenditure positively influences a nation’s economic performance in most cases, governments should factor in the level of economic development when choosing specific areas of investment based on the requirements of national labour markets.

'Investments in education in emerging economies must be phased: the top priority should be the primary education of the entire population, followed by professional training programmes commensurate with the level of economic and technological development. Only by doing this will government expenditure promote GDP growth, as is the case in developed economies,' Professor Kolosnitsyna concluded.

See also:

Economists Suggest Using Media's Attention to Bitcoin to Predict its Returns

Researchers at the HSE Faculty of Economic Sciences have studied the relationship between the changes in the bitcoin prices and the media attention to this cryptocurrency. The researchers examined the mentions of bitcoin in the media between 2017 and 2021 and built a mathematical model that revealed the strong relationship between media attention and bitcoin prices. The study was published in the Applied Stochastic Models in Business and Industry journal.

HSE Economists Develop a Model for Sustainable Solar Geoengineering Agreements

Researchers at HSE University and George Mason University have investigated the sustainability of prospective international agreements on solar geoengineering. The authors have proposed a scheme in which payments flow from affluent nations to less wealthy ones; an arrangement which sets their proposal apart from traditional systems. The proposed model aims to dissuade more vulnerable countries from excessive use of the prevalent geoengineering method by providing compensation for the potential damage they may incur and supporting their adaptation to climate change. The paper has been published in Environmental and Resource Economics.

Crypto Investors Receive Downside Risk Premiums

Victoria Dobrynskaya, Assistant Professor at the HSE Faculty of Economic Sciences, has analysed the price dynamics of 2,000 cryptocurrencies from 2014 to 2021 and investigated the association between downside risks and average returns in the cryptocurrency market. As it turns out, cryptocurrencies exhibiting a greater risk tend to yield higher average returns. The study has been published in International Review of Financial Analysis.

Results of the Contest to Predict Nobel Prize Winners in Economics

Claudia Goldin's award was predicted by five people. They are Olga Peresypkina (RSVPU), Anastasia Sirotina (first-year student of the Bachelor's in Applied Mathematics and Information Science at HSE University), Mikhail Shabanov (Global Vision Asset Management LLC), Tatul Hayrapetyan (PhD student at the Stanford Graduate School of Business), and Hemant Kumar (Ettumanoorappan College, Kerala, India).

Financial Sector Risks Can Hinder Transition to Green Economy

According to HSE and MGIMO economists, increased financial sector risks in developed countries may be associated with a higher carbon footprint in banks' loan portfolios. This is likely due to the fact that in response to an unstable economic situation, banks tend to issue more loans to companies that have a detrimental impact on the environment. Although this might yield short-term profits for the banks, such trends hinder humanity's progress towards achieving a green economy. The paper has been published in Environmental Science and Pollution Research.

Winner of 2023 Nobel Prize in Economics Announced

The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has awarded the Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel 2023 to Claudia Goldin (Harvard University, Cambridge, MA, USA), ‘for having advanced our understanding of women’s labour market outcomes.’ According to the Nobel committee, Professor Goldin has uncovered key factors that determine gender differences in the labour market.

Millennials Are Three Times Ahead of Zoomers in the Monetised Creator Economy. Even Boomers Outperform Them. Okay Then…

A group of specialists from the HSE Institute for Cultural Studies, Vitaly Kurennoy, Alexander Suvalko and Maria Figura, have determined two main trends that are actively shaping the image of the creative economy and culture in 2021-2023: the creator economy and the maker economy.

A University's Special Status Is Correlated with a Substantial Increase in Salaries for Graduates

A university education is a highly sought-after commodity in Russia, yet the quality of universities and their programmes varies significantly. This gives rise to risks of inequality, both in the realm of education and in the labour market, and subsequently impacts the returns on higher education, which are manifested in the salaries earned by graduates. According to a study by Ilya Prakhov, Assistant Professor of the HSE Faculty of Economic Sciences, graduates from Russia’s top-tier universities enjoy a distinct advantage. The paper has been published in the International Journal of Educational Development.

HSE University and Moscow Planetarium Sign Cooperation Agreement

The parties will work to popularise science and conduct educational and research activities, including in the fields of astronomy, cosmonautics, and Earth science. The agreement also covers the implementation of joint practical programmes and internships for students.

Teaching Masters' Students and Conducting Lectures in English Boost Academic Productivity

HSE researchers have analysed teaching load data at the HSE campus in St Petersburg to investigate the potential impact of teaching on faculty research output. They found that factors such as teaching primarily masters' courses, conducting 20% of lectures in English, and supervising only one doctoral student per year were associated with a greater likelihood of producing more high-quality academic papers. The study has been published in Higher Education Quarterly.