• A
  • A
  • A
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
Regular version of the site

‘Today, Ethical Questions Are Front and Centre’

‘Today, Ethical Questions Are Front and Centre’

Photo by engin akyurt on Unsplash

The conference on Philosophy and Culture in Time of Pandemics ran from September 30 to 2 October 2021. It was divided into seven sessions held in a hybrid format. The organizers and participants discussed major topics such as social transformation during the pandemic, the role of mass media in shaping perceptions of the pandemic, and the epistemological and ethical issues that have arisen as a result.

The conference was organized by the HSE University School of Philosophy and Cultural Studies in collaboration with the HSE Faculty of Law, the Pirogov Russian National Research Medical University, the Department of Social Philosophy at the Russian Academy of Sciences, the Faculty of Philosophy of the Russian State University for the Humanities, and the Society of Professional Sociologists. Over 100 people took part in the discussions, including Russian and international experts.

Anastasia Ugleva, Head of the School of Philosophy and Cultural Studies

Our conference has been running for twelve years. We have set up our own space dedicated to internal dialogue and the exchange of ideas. We want to give a wider circle of colleagues the opportunity to review our results, debate them and join research groups.

At some point, we realized that the generalized nature of the conference was outdated, and that it would be more interesting and productive to narrow its focus. This changes the makeup of the participants and makes our goals more global in scope. What’s more, we are now engaged in major projects (such as our megaproject in applied ethics) that combine groups from multiple HSE departments, different campuses, and external colleagues.

Experience shows that students are benefitting from this decision too. Many are engaged in project work and have seamlessly adapted to the new format. I’d like to point out that the professionalism of our students grows from year to year. We have a lot of shared areas of interest and we have long viewed our students as colleagues.

The topic of the conference was prompted by our current reality. The pandemic brought people together, and the problems we discussed were of interest to everyone, despite the wide variety of fields represented (there were sessions on sociology, law, philosophy and cultural studies).

We wanted to shed light on the social, philosophical, ethical, and legal issues that have arisen as a result of the pandemic, as well as those that we have had to look at from a new perspective 

We devoted a lot of attention to questions of medical philosophy and problems in modern public healthcare, timely issues at the crossroads of ethics and law, questions of responsibility and free will, and the so-called ‘infodemic.’

The inevitable conclusion is that social issues have become more acute, as has the need for collective problem solving in the fields of health, social and psychological adaptation to new circumstances, communication, self-presentation in the new space, and defending citizens’ rights. If we can’t solve these issues, it will be difficult to maintain social balance. Today, ethical questions are front and centre.

A society without morality is unsustainable. But morals are not a fixed thing; they transform, and are often ignored, but they become essential in times of global crisis

Jovan Babić, Professor of Ethics at the University of Belgrade, Serbia

I am interested in the issues of life and death and other issues in Bioethics. Also, I was always interested in the concept of human conflict (and its many forms). I hope that this might be a promising framework for future cooperation with HSE University. I plan to give a lecture there on Applied Ethics and its main problems later this year.

My talk at the conference was entitled Logic of Catastrophe – Deeper Logic of Reality. We are living in an age of a specific ideology of rights, and rights are usually taken as sacrosanct and inalienable. However, during catastrophes, we see the real nature of rights: an exchange of claims and privileges we make with each other, showing that rights are based in a deeper realm of reality, which is a set of basic long-term interests and constraints. 

If we go even deeper into the logic of pandemics, in part independent of the logic of catastrophes, we can question whether the aspiration to avoid vaccination is valid at all. We can say that everybody has the right to jump off a bridge (with the intention to commit suicide) on the condition that not everyone does it, but we can also say that nobody has the right to push others off bridges (with the intent, for example, to see what happens). If the intent to avoid vaccination is more similar to pushing others from bridges than jumping off them, we may derive the conclusion that the ‘right to non-vaccination’ is not tenable at all, not even as an exception.

In a way, all this might be seen as the old skepticism issue. But if we include the concepts of temporality and responsibility (not to mention two other very important and basic concepts: fallibility and vulnerability), the matter becomes serious and, possibly, connected to a deeper layer of normativity: its valid and justified enforcement.

Session on the Ethics, Epistemology and Biopolitics of Medicine in the Era of Coronavirus

Ivan Kuzin, Instructor, HSE University School of Philosophy and Cultural Studies

Grigoriy Chasovskikh, Senior Lecturer, UNESCO Network Chair in Bioethics and International Medical Law at Pirogov Russian National Research Medical University

The majority of speakers examined ethical issues, predominantly those concerning applied and professional ethics. Another common theme was the COVID-19 ‘infodemic,’ its impact and ways of counteracting it. Multiple speakers discussed issues at the intersection of epistemology and ethics, examining the pandemic through the lens of epistemic virtues. Several speakers touched on ontological issues (the relationship between the body and mind, the interpretation of the virus as a process) and biopolitics.

Session on the Temporality and Topology of the Pandemic

Anna Ganzha, Associate Professor, HSE University School of Philosophy and Cultural Studies

The redirection and restriction of tourist flows and the transformation of recreational practices produced a unique collective cultural experience. This semi-voluntary experience forms a new realm full of forgotten discourse about homelands, nostalgia, blame, presence and admiration for the landscape.

Pressing ethical topics of discussion included inequality and the reintegration of the meaning of concepts such as ‘accommodation,’ ‘home,’ ‘work,’ ‘everyday time,’ and ‘working time.’ The specific structure of the pandemic’s affect has caused factors such as anxiety and uncertainty to function in a new way, locking them into a hopeless cycle. Other important issues of discussion included changes in temporal metaphorics and their transformation into a pandemic ‘war machine.’

Session on the Coronavirus and Geopolitics

Boris Kashnikov, Professor, School of Philosophy and Cultural Studies

In our session, we looked at the links between the pandemic and geopolitical issues. Our goal was to understand how centres of political influence have been changing during the pandemic. The pandemic is used as a way to gain leverage by fighting for prestige over one vaccine or another, as well as over proposed quarantine measures.

Our overall conclusion was that the issue of security in society is underdeveloped. Until now, it has been focused on threats such as war and terrorism, but it is philosophically unhelpful in the face of the pandemic. We have no ethical studies of the corresponding moral values on the global or national scale.

Session on Crisis Society: Meeting the Challenges of the Pandemic

Tatiana Sidorina, Research Professor, HSE University School of Philosophy and Cultural Studies

Anatoliy Ovsyannikov, Professor, RANEPA Institute of Business

The organizers and participants of this session set themselves the goal of addressing the issue of global epidemiological collapse in the context of a wide range of social issues. Key areas of focus included how modern society is living during the pandemic, what has changed in social measurement, whether society has fundamentally stayed the same, how social philosophy and social theory assess ongoing changes, and how social institutions react to changes during the pandemic.

Vladislav Karelin, Associate Professor, Russian State University for the Humanities Department of Social Philosophy

As part of the session on Crisis Society: Meeting the Challenges of the Pandemic, we held a roundtable on ‘The Epidemic as a Challenge: The Transformation and Deformation of Society.’

There are two main areas of pressing interest. The first concerns the understanding of issues in daily life through individual relationships to the experience of new activities and their corresponding social roles (vaccination, isolation and self-isolation, mandatory administrative practices, etc). The second concerns various aspects of wary attitudes to uncertainty and social crises that require new forms of social adaptation.

Session on Social-Philosophical Futurology

Nikolai Afanasov, Junior Research Fellow, Institute of Philosophy, Russian Academy of Sciences

While there was a wide range of topics at this year’s conference, we can divide them into several main areas: new and old forms of capitalism and their influence on the future, information technologies and our day-to-day lives, the political and legal aspects of the new world, and fantasy and literature as figurative modes of thought.

The joint work of participants demonstrated the lack of alternatives to capitalism as a unifying research lens. Inequality, loneliness, and decentralization of subjectivity have only become more pronounced during the pandemic. Both people’s inner world and the most abstract social norms are derived from existing resources. Information technologies are becoming not only an objective reality that reshapes the world, but also technological determinants of social processes.

There was a new addition to the session in the form of a block of presentations on the legal aspects of the behaviour of the pandemic and the digital future. It was prepared by students of the HSE University Faculty of Law (Yulia Erokhina’s Law and Culture project).

Session on the Ethics and Philosophy of Law

Anton Didikin, Professor, HSE University Faculty of Law

In this session, we discussed theoretical questions surrounding the formalization of ethical directives and the implementation of ethical indicators in the legal system of the modern state. The speakers highlighted examples of the successful implementation of formal and mathematical logical methods in legal discourse (which are similar in terms of regulating people’s behaviour), and ways of justifying the existence of moral foundations in any real or hypothetical system. The speakers also tried to shed light on the idea of value arguments, which is important in ensuring just legal decisions.  

A selection of the most interesting presentations will be published. A conference primarily dedicated to ethical issues is currently planned for 2022.

See also:

School in the Pandemic: How Online Learning Has Worsened Inequality

At the start of the pandemic, countries over the world struggled to provide a high-quality combination of online and in-person education. What’s more, low-income families have had fewer opportunities to arrange education for their children. These issues were the topic of the open seminar on ‘International Experience: Lessons for Schools After the Stress of the Pandemic’ hosted by the HSE University Institute of Education.

HSE University Strengthens Ties with Netherlands in Agricultural Research and Education

On November 9, 2021, HSE University signed a memorandum of understanding with Wageningen University & Research, a major university in the Netherlands and one of the leading agricultural research institutes in the world. Participants of the signing ceremony included HSE University Rector Nikita Anisimov, President of the Wageningen University & Research Executive Board Professor Louise Fresco, and Dutch Ambassador to Russia Gilles Beschoor Plug.

The Majority of Russians Do Not Support Microchip Implants

The majority of Russians would not agree to being fitted with microchip implants for any purposes—medical or otherwise. A joint study conducted by HSE University’s International Laboratory for Applied Network Research and Aventica found that respondents believe the risks of personal data leaks and misuse to be too high.

‘We Can Now Say That the Finance Conference Is Global’

The 10th International Moscow Finance Conference, organized by HSE ICEF, took place on October 29–30 online. Vladimir Sokolov, Head of the International Laboratory of Financial Economics, which hosted the conference, talks about the participants, the key presentation topics and how they will impact the global economy.

HSE University Scholars Study Green Transition Risks and Greenhouse Gas Emission Regulation

The UN Climate Change Conference is taking place from October 31 to November 12 in Glasgow. The conference focuses on preventive measures against the catastrophic and irreversible consequences of rising average global air temperatures. Igor Makarov, Head of the HSE Laboratory for Economics of Climate Change, will be taking part in the Glasgow conference. In the following interview, he speaks about the pressing problems Russia and the world are facing, and the research HSE scholars are doing on climate change.

Applications to Speak at eSTARS 2021 Conference Accepted Until November 15

HSE University and Coursera are bringing together the world’s leading researchers, professionals, education and technology leaders, and business community representatives for the fourth international research conference eLearning Stakeholders and Researchers Summit 2021 (eSTARS). This topic of this year’s summit, which will run from December 1–2, 2021,is ‘Digital Transformation: Global Challenges to the Education System’.

Culture, Arts, Creative Industries, and Tourism Discussed at HSE University’s Conference in Perm

On October 20–22, the second International Conference on Experience Economy: Museum, Event, and Tourism Management was held at HSE University in Perm. Key talks were delivered by Andrea Rurale, the director of the Master’s in Arts Management and Administration at the Bocconi University School of Management, and Guillaume Tiberghien, University of Glasgow.

Model of Predator-Prey Relationship Helps Predict Spread of COVID-19

Researchers from the HSE Faculty of Economic Sciences have proposed a mathematical model that describes the course of the COVID-19 pandemic, taking into account the restrictions applied in different countries. The model will help governments make reasonable and timely decisions on introducing or lifting restrictions. The paper was published in Eurasian Economic Review.

Researchers Discuss How the Pandemic Is Changing Civic Activism

In October, HSE University held the 10th Conference of Civil Society Researchers, organized by the Centre for Studies of Civil Society and Nonprofit Sector. The main topic of this anniversary forum was ‘The impact of the crisis on the development of the nonprofit sector and citizen self-organization in Russia: New realities and prospects’. The conference was co-organized by the Association "European University for Volunteering" (EUV) and the United Nations Volunteers Programme (UNV), a long-time partner of the centre.

Ageing and Frailty: International Study and Seminar

In October, a two-day seminar entitled ‘Ageing and frailty in Norway and Russia’ was held by HSE University’s International Laboratory for Population and Health.  In addition to purely demographic results concerning the changing age structure of the population and growing life expectancy, most presentations were devoted to the comparative assessment of physical and cognitive status among elderly people, cardiovascular aging, as well as social and medical support for the elderly. We spoke with the organizers and participants of the seminar about their research findings and the implications for society and public health.