Foresight is More Prescience than Prognosis
As part of the project “The International Academy of Foresight” the Foresight Centre at the HSE Institute of Statistical Studies and Economics of Knowledge (ISSEK) is receiving its first interns from partner universities. Tiina-Maria Seppänen, researcher at Zurich University of Applied Sciences (ZHAW), and Alexander Chulok, head of department at ISSEK, talked to us about their joint research plans.
— The Academy is the first ever consortium to unite foresight research organisations from more than ten countries. Its mission sounds quite ambitious: “Foresight to develop democracy” and implies a wide range of research projects on very varied subjects. Leading world centres in foresight and prognosis are involved: The Austrian Institute of Technology (AIT), The Finland Futures Research Centre at the University of Turku (UTU), The Centre for Strategic Studies in Management and Science (CGEE) Brazil, The Latin American School of Social Sciences (FLACSO) Argentina, Foresight Canada, The Science and Technology Policy Institute (STEPI) South Korea and others.
Around the world Foresight has been developing as a concept for more than 40 years, but has only been growing in Russia in the last 15 years. This makes it all the more important for us to look at the experience of our colleagues and to learn from their mistakes. On the other hand, Foresight as a science has reached such a level of complexity, skill and experience that it wouldn’t be untimely to discuss some kind of harmonisation. It’s time to talk about the need to make general standards for quality, a unified system to connect the centres which are doing Foresight research. So among the key tasks for the academy is to develop joint international research projects, to increase mobility of young academics and to make an international expert network on the basis of the participating organisations. The project will start when it gets support from the European Commission under the Marie Curie Prize competitions, and is expected to last three years coordinated by AIT. During that time, more than 150 researchers will be brought in, some quite young and others more experienced, and there will be summer and winter schools, an academic seminar and a concluding conference.
— What role does HSE’s Foresight Centre play in the academy?
— HSE has joined the process on an equal footing, which I think is an objective indication of the quality of our research. Although Foresight has only recently become part of Russia’s innovation and science and technology policy we already have a clear sense of why we are doing it and which is the proper approach for us to use. But it’s also important that we synchronize our purpose with the research of our foreign colleagues, so every year at the International consultative council of the Foresight Centre we discuss the latest trends and influences in Foresight research.
Through the academy we plan to organise more than 20 internships for our staff and for colleagues from partner organisations in leading European centres involved in research about the future. Our foreign colleagues showed a keen interest in coming to study with us. Among the first is the young researcher from the Institute of Sustainable Development at the Zurich University of Applied Sciences, Tiina-Maria Seppänen.
— In Russia these days the word “foresight” is used quite a lot but not always in the right way. What do you understand foresight and foresight research to mean?
— Foresight has many factors, but essentially it is the systematic research and creation of a general picture of the future of the economy and society, divided by key stakeholders. By key we mean stakeholders like business, consumers, science, higher education, the state and, ideally, society. Getting them involved is one of the necessary conditions of effective Foresight. And we need a systematic approach. It’s no use doing Foresight research and then just going away and not applying it usefully, or adjusting it when new dangers or new opportunities arise. Foresight is more prescience than prognosis. It’s difficult to predict the future but you can make agreements about it, and those agreements can be more important than a correct prognosis. In Russia at the moment, where although we have so many opportunities for communicating, business and science continue “not to see” each other, applying the ideas of Foresight could become a powerful tool to integrate their interests.
Foresight has absorbed approaches from many different areas – marketing, sociology, economics and management and could provide useful material for expert discussions and the right framework to develop a script for the future.
In recent years Russia has moved away from short-term 3-4 year planning. It’s noticeable among companies who are initiating 10 year projects and in government policy making that most industrial strategies, regional and national plans are calculated up to 2030 and beyond. Evidently, without a picture of the future with all the possible changes and variations included, it is extremely difficult to make the right executive decision now. We need road maps which show the many possible solutions, and alternative strategies to realise them, taking into account the constant changes in the situation around us. I think that’s another strong argument in favour of Foresight.
— What opportunities does the internship programme for young researchers offer?
— We are running quite a broad range of Foresight research projects, including national, regional, industrial and corporative foresight as well as international projects like ERANET.RUS or Rising Powers.
So, there are lots of areas of mutual interest. For example, as part of the long-term prognosis for science and technology development in Russia up to 2030 which we are coordinating under the Ministry of Education and Science, six priority areas have been chosen for research. They include information and telecommunication systems, life sciences, new materials and nanotechnology, transport and space systems, rational use of natural resources, energy and energy efficiency. For each of these we looked at global trends, future and innovative markets, products and services, priority applied research and development.
It’s important that alone we cannot cover every interesting niche, and there are many challenges on a global level like ageing populations and energy security which need a collective, interdisciplinary and international response. Here we need to integrate the chain to create added value, there we need partnership to carry out research or transfer competencies.
We hope that the various joint projects of the academy will allow us to outline zones of mutual interest with potential partners and to bring up proponents of Foresight culture who in a short time will be able to use their research to demonstrate the usefulness of Foresight.
For example, Tiina-Maria Seppänen is studying sustainable development and her subject is the ecology of transport systems. This presents a lot of complex problems which can only be resolved in cooperation with different specialists and so we’ve planned a series of meetings with colleagues from different departments at HSE and with our partners at Moscow State University at the Centre for Prognosis in the Rational Use of Natural Resources. I think Tiina can tell you in more detail about her research.
Tiina-Maria Seppänen, a Pioneer of the International Foresight Academy in Moscow
Tiina -Maria Seppanen
Tiina-Maria Seppänen, M.Sc. in Environmental Sciences, is a research assistant at Zurich University of Applied Sciences (ZHAW) in Switzerland. She is currently in Moscow working for the project of the International Foresight Academy.
— What are your interests in research?
My interests in research are focusing on sustainability and more precisely on sustainable mobility and the future issues relating to transport and resources. My research includes future trends and key drivers as well as challenges and opportunities for the future transportation. Socio-economic and environmental aspects, spatial differences in versatile developments, indicators for sustainable mobility and technical solutions as a way for creating an accessible, sustainable and efficient transport system are essential parts of my research.
— How long have you been working in this areas in Switzerland? What are the main problems and goals?
— I have been working in the field of sustainable mobility at the Institute of Sustainable Development (INE) at Zurich University of Applied Sciences (ZHAW) in Switzerland for two years. I have a master’s degree in Environmental Sciences, which also included topics relating to sustainability, energy and transportation. My master’s thesis was about biogas as an energy source for heating and transportation. During the past years I have been working on several EU and other projects focusing on current and future mobility issues and including different foresight methods.
Switzerland has an advanced public transport system with frequent connections and good infrastructure, but issues relating to peak hours and unequal capacity use, financing, land use and spatial development exist. The different urban, suburban and rural areas in Switzerland have versatile issues when it comes to accessibility and sustainable transportation, which is one of the reasons why we at INE are trying to find ways to measure and analyse sustainable mobility nationwide in Switzerland. Infrastructure financing and the internalisation of the external costs, which are the negative environmental and social impacts caused by transportation, are also central issues in Switzerland.
— You are the pioneer of International Foresight Academy in HSE. What are your expectations and challenges in working in Moscow?
— I’m looking forward for learning about the transport related foresight and about the future trends, challenges and opportunities for the transportation in Russia. I would also like to get to know about the framework requirements and key drivers influencing the mobility patterns in Russia and finally to be able to compare the situations in Russia and in Switzerland / in the EU. It will be interesting to look at the differences and similarities and to create cooperation based on the common interests. A joint output in the form of a paper or article would be a desirable result.
— What's your first impression on Moscow?
— I’m really enjoying Moscow. It’s an exciting city and has numerous grand buildings and churches where the remarkable history and culture can be seen. It can be a small cultural shock when coming from central Europe, but not in a negative sense. I’m also surprised how well the metro system is working and how easy it is to get around in Moscow.
— How do you see development of International Foresight Academy in the nearest future?
— Since I am the pioneer of IFA, I can’t say for sure how it will develop, but I’m convinced that exciting knowledge exchange and positive learning experiences will be a part of IFA’s future. Further plans for international exchange between European and South and North American countries is already been planned.
Ludmilla Mezentseva and Anna Chernyakhovskaya, HSE news portal
This summer, students of Asian Studies at HSE Lyceum spent a month in China. They studied at Liaoning Normal University, visited ancient temples, and met the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO) Secretary-General. The students spoke to HSE News Service about their trip.
This May, HSE and the Science and Technology Policy Institute (STEPI, Republic of Korea) signed a cooperation agreement on science and advanced technology research. This agreement was signed by Leonid Gokhberg, HSE First Vice Rector, Director of the Institute for Statistical Studies and Economics of Knowledge, and Dr. Hwang-Hee Cho, STEPI President.
The HSE Centre for Psychological Counseling has been offering internships for master’s students in psychology for five years. Students from HSE, as well as from other universities, can get an internship. Here’s more information on how the programme works and the opportunities it offers.
Following years of study and work in South America and Europe, Rafael Popper joined HSE Moscow as Professor of Foresight and STI Governance in January 2018. In addition to his job at HSE, he is Principal Scientist in Business, Innovation and Foresight at a world leading research and technology organization (RTO) called VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland. With a PhD on 21st Century Foresight from the University of Manchester, Popper has built a career on wide-ranging research of issues in foresight and STI policy. In a recent interview with the HSE News Service, he spoke in depth about his research interests, philosophy on teaching, collaboration across HSE and his love of languages, among other topics.
Leonid Gokhberg, HSE First Vice Rector, Director of the Institute for Statistical Studies and Economics of Knowledge, spoke on his first steps in academia, working with foreign researchers, on foresight research as well as shared his thoughts on HSE research development.
On November 7, HSE hosted a delegation from the Jülich Research Centre in Germany. Scholars from both countries came together to discuss joint research opportunities, including transformation of energy systems for sustainable development; future studies of energy technologies, including foresight studies; and methodological issues related to big data analysis and modelling.
Carlos Cortez, a bronze medallist of the International Mathematical Olympiad (2011, 2012, 2013) and a Mathematics graduate of MIT, recently completed a two-month research internship at the HSE Faculty of Mathematics under the supervision of Professor Sergei Lando. He will soon be pursuing a Master’s degree at University Paris-Sud in France followed by a PhD at Northwestern University (USA). The research internship was made possible through a cooperation agreement between MIT International Science and Technology Initiatives (MISTI) and HSE.
Over the course of three months, 11 students from the HSE Faculty of Computer Science interned for Google at the company’s offices in the U.S., Switzerland, Germany, Great Britain, and Poland. The HSE News Service spoke with several of these students and learned how they got the internships, how Google treats its interns, and whether or not a refrigerator full of ice cream interferes with the work process.
Last week, HSE’s Doing Business in Russia internship programme held an integration module for students who have completed their 6-month internships at German enterprises based in Russia and students who have just arrived in Russia. Those completing the programme presented group projects on a variety of topics, including project management, intercultural relations, and expat experiences. They also shared their impressions with new participants.
Policymakers are increasingly turning to foresight techniques for guidance when addressing the wide array of problems and challenges arising in their work. A new book co-edited by Leonid Gokhberg, Dirk Meissner, and Alexander Sokolov from the HSE Institute for Statistical Studies and Economics of Knowledge (ISSEK), attempts to add another dimension – namely, opportunities – that can come from proper application of foresight techniques. Deploying Foresight for Policy and Strategy Makers: Creating Opportunities Through Public Policies and Corporate Strategies in Science, Technology and Innovation (Springer, 2016) features essays by more than a dozen scholars on various aspects of foresight application in today’s policy environment.