Andrey Subochev
- Associate Professor:Faculty of Economic Sciences / Department of Mathematics
- Senior Research Fellow:International Centre of Decision Choice and Analysis
- Andrey Subochev has been at HSE University since 1999.
Education and Degrees
- 2009
Candidate of Sciences* (PhD) in Mathematical Modelling, Numerical Methods and Software Complexes
HSE University
Thesis Title: Social choice solution concepts - 1999
Master's in Economic sociology
HSE University - 1996
Degree in Physics
Lomonosov Moscow State University
According to the International Standard Classification of Education (ISCED) 2011, Candidate of Sciences belongs to ISCED level 8 - "doctoral or equivalent", together with PhD, DPhil, D.Lit, D.Sc, LL.D, Doctorate or similar. Candidate of Sciences allows its holders to reach the level of the Associate Professor.
Continuing education / Professional retraining / Internships / Study abroad experience
2017 The 28th Jerusalem School in Economic Theory
Topic: Mechanism Design
Israel Institute for Advanced Studies, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
27.06.2017 - 06.07.2017 Jerusalem, Israel
Courses (2022/2023)
- Calculus (Bachelor’s programme; Graduate School of Business; 1 year, 1-4 module)Rus
- Calculus (Bachelor’s programme; Graduate School of Business; 1 year, 3, 4 module)Eng
- Probability Theory and Mathematical Statistics (Bachelor’s programme; Graduate School of Business; 1 year, 4 module)Eng
- Past Courses
Courses (2020/2021)
- Calculus (Bachelor’s programme; Faculty of Economic Sciences; 1 year, 1-4 module)Rus
- Calculus (Bachelor’s programme; Graduate School of Business; 1 year, 3, 4 module)Rus
- Calculus 1 (Bachelor’s programme; Faculty of Economic Sciences; 1 year, 1, 2 module)Rus
Courses (2017/2018)
- Calculus (Bachelor’s programme; Graduate School of Business; 1 year, 1-4 module)Rus
- Calculus (Bachelor’s programme; Graduate School of Business; 2 year, 1, 2 module)Rus
Grants
Erasmus+ International Credit Mobility Programme
Academic mobility grant for teaching staff to undertake an academic stay during the academic year 2018/19 (06-10.05.2019) at the University of Latvia (Riga)
Erasmus+ International Credit Mobility Programme (Action KA107)
Alliance 4 Universities
Academic mobility grant for teaching staff to undertake an academic stay during the academic year 2016/17 (31.10-04.11.2016) at Universidad Autónoma de Barcelona (Autonomous University of Barselona)
Conferences
- 2022
Заседание департамента математики факультета экономических наук НИУ ВШЭ (Москва). Presentation: Таксономия Блума предполагаемых результатов обучения (ПРО) и её использование при планировании учебной дисциплины
XXIII Ясинская (Апрельская) международная научная конференция по проблемам развития экономики и общества (Москва). Presentation: Устойчивые турнирные решения как инструменты для принятия оптимальных решений: проблема обобщения двухпартийного множества на случай неполных предпочтений
- 2021
Совместное заседание Общемосковского семинара "Экспертные оценки и анализ данных" Института проблем управления им. Трапезникова РАН и научного семинара Международного центра анализа и выбора решений НИУ ВШЭ (Москва). Presentation: Существенное множество: теоретические свойства и практическое применение
- 2020
Научный семинар Международного центра анализа и выбора решений НИУ ВШЭ (Москва). Presentation: Обсуждение статьи А.Пастора-Бернье, Ч.Плотта, В.Шульца "Monkeys choose as if maximizing utility compatible with basic principles of revealed preference theory"
Общемосковский семинар "Экспертные оценки и анализ данных" (Москва). Presentation: Всё, что мне известно об устойчивых множествах: определения, характеризации, соотношения, обобщения, интерпретации
IV Российский экономический конгресс (РЭК-2020) (Москва). Presentation: О выборе победителя в турнире: теория и приложения (в рамках круглого стола "Индивидуальный выбор и задачи агрегирования - современное состояние и приложения")
- 2019
15th European Meeting on Game Theory (Турку). Presentation: Nash implementability and related properties of the union of externally stable sets
- Осенняя школа "Современные методы и модели теории индивидуального и коллективного выбора и принятия решений с применением к сетевому анализу данных, задачам агрегирования, индексам влияния" (Москва). Presentation: Nash implementability and related properties of the union of externally stable sets
Семинар кафедры междисциплинарных исследований в мировой экономике (9 мая 2019 г.) (Рига). Presentation: Aggregation of preferences: impossibilities and possibilities
- 2018
Общемосковский семинар «Проблемы организации и управления научными исследованиями и разработками» (Москва). Presentation: Популярные библиометрические индикаторы: сходства и различия
23rd International Conference on Science and Technology Indicators (STI 2018) (Leiden). Presentation: With or without h-index? Comparing aggregates of rankings based on seven popular bibliometric indicators
Осенняя школа «Современные тренды в теории принятия решений» (Москва). Presentation: Aggregation of journal rankings: an example of application of social choice in scientometrics
Семинар Международной лаборатории анализа и выбора решений (заседание 1-2 сентября) (Москва). Presentation: Аксиоматический и эмпирический анализ способов многокритериального ранжирования в контексте проблемы оценки научных журналов
- 2017
The 7-th Murat Sertel Workshop on Economic Design, Decision, Institutions and Organization (Москва). Presentation: Axiomatic analysis of the union of minimal externally stable sets concerning application and implementation of this novel social choice correspondence
Годовая конференция Новой Экономической Ассоциации "Политические системы и экономическое развитие: проблемы взаимосвязи" (Москва). Presentation: Новый подход в библиометрии: использование методов теории коллективного выбора для ранжирования журналов
- 2016
XVII Апрельская международная научная конференция по проблемам развития экономики и общества (Москва). Presentation: О возможности имплементации такой функции коллективного выбора, как объединение минимальных внешнеустойчивых множеств, и о других ее полезных свойствах и возможностях применения
21st International Conference on Science and Technology Indicators (Валенсия). Presentation: Ranking Journals Using Social Choice Theory Methods: A Novel Approach in Bibliometrics
- IAE/DEHE Games and Social Choice Internal Seminar - совместный научный семинар Института экономического анализа (IAE) и департамента экономики и экономической истории (DEHE) Автономного университета Барселоны (UAB) (Барселона). Presentation: Axiomatic analysis of the union of minimal externally stable sets concerning application and implementation of this novel social choice correspondence
- 201326th European conference on operational research (Рим). Presentation: Alternative versions of the Global Competitiveness Ranking: a Social Choice approach
Dissertation for a degree of Candidate of Science
A. Subochev Концепции решений в задаче коллективного выбора
Publications17
- Article Subochev A., Fuad Aleskerov, Pislyakov V. Ranking journals using social choice theory methods: A novel approach in bibliometrics // Journal of Informetrics. 2018. Vol. 12. No. 2. P. 416-429. doi
- Chapter Subochev A., Pislyakov V. With or without h-index? Comparing aggregates of rankings based on seven popular bibliometric indicators, in: STI 2018 Conference Proceedings. Proceedings of the 23rd International Conference on Science and Technology Indicators. Leiden : Universiteit Leiden - CWTS, 2018. P. 1135-1143.
- Chapter Субочев А. Н. О возможности имплементации такой функции коллективного выбора, как объединение минимальных внешнеустойчивых множеств, и о других ее полезных свойствах и возможностях применения // В кн.: XVII Апрельская международная научная конференция по проблемам развития экономики и общества: в 4 кн. / Отв. ред.: Е. Г. Ясин. Кн. 1. М. : Издательский дом НИУ ВШЭ, 2017. С. 111-120.
- Chapter Aleskerov F. T., Pislyakov V., Subochev A. Ranking Journals Using Social Choice Theory Methods: A Novel Approach in Bibliometrics, in: Proceedings of the 21 International Conference on Science and Technology Indicators. Valencia : Editorial Universitat Politècnica de València, 2016. doi Ch. 16. P. 1266-1273. doi
- Article Субочев А. Н. Насколько различны существующие рейтинги российских научных журналов по экономике и менеджменту и как их объединить // Журнал Новой экономической ассоциации. 2016. № 2(30). С. 181-192. doi
- Preprint Subochev A., Zakhlebin I. V. Alternative versions of the global competitive industrial performance ranking constructed by methods from social choice theory / Издательский дом ВШЭ. Series WP7 "Математические методы анализа решений в экономике, бизнесе и политике". 2014. No. 6.
- Preprint Aleskerov F. T., Pislyakov V., Subochev A. Ranking Journals In Economics, Management And Political Science By Social Choice Theory Methods / NRU Higher School of Economics. Series WP BRP "Science, Technology and Innovation". 2014. No. WP BRP 27/STI/2014.
- Article Aleskerov F. T., Subochev A. Modeling optimal social choice: matrix-vector representation of various solution concepts based on majority rule // Journal of Global Optimization. 2013. Vol. 56. No. 2. P. 737-756. doi
- Preprint Субочев А. Н., Алескеров Ф. Т., Писляков В. В. Построение рейтингов журналов по экономике с помощью методов теории коллективного выбора / Издательский дом ВШЭ. Серия WP7 "Математические методы анализа решений в экономике, бизнесе и политике". 2013. № 3.
- Preprint Алескеров Ф. Т., Писляков В. В., Субочев А. Н., Чистяков А. Г. Построение рейтингов журналов по менеджменту с помощью методов теории коллективного выбора / Высшая школа экономики. Серия WP7 "Математические методы анализа решений в экономике, бизнесе и политике". 2011. № 04.
- Article Subochev A. Dominating, weakly stable, and uncovered sets: Properties and generalizations // Automation and Remote Control. 2010. Vol. 71. No. 1. P. 116-127. doi
- Article Субочев А. Н. Доминирующие, слабоустойчивые и непокрытые множества: свойства и обобщения // Автоматика и телемеханика. 2010. № 1. С. 130-143.
- Preprint Aleskerov F. T., Subochev A. Matrix-vector representation of various solution concepts / NRU Higher School of Economics. Series WP7 "Математические методы анализа решений в экономике, бизнесе и политике". 2009. No. 3.
- Article Aleskerov F. T., Subochev A. On Stable Solutions to the Ordinal Social Choice Problem / Пер. с рус.: A. Subochev. // Доклады Академии наук. 2009. Vol. 79. No. 3. P. 437-439. doi
- Article Алескеров Ф. Т., Субочев А. Н. Об устойчивых решениях в ординальной задаче выбора // Доклады Академии Наук. Информатика. 2009. Т. 426. № 3. С. 318-320.
- Preprint Subochev A. Dominant, Weakly Stable, Uncovered Sets: Properties and Extensions / NRU Higher School of Economics. Series WP7 "Математические методы анализа решений в экономике, бизнесе и политике". 2008. No. 3.
- Article Субочев А. Н. Российская политическая реформа и интеграционные процессы в СНГ: проблемы и тупики. Комментарии // Полития: Анализ. Хроника. Прогноз. 2004. № 3
Employment history
02.2015 – present Associate Professor, Department of Mathematics, Faculty of Economic Sciences, National Research University Higher School of Economics
12.2009 – present Senior Researcher, Decision Choice and Analysis Laboratory (DeCAn Lab), National Research University Higher School of Economics.
07.2010 – 01.2015 Associate Professor, Chair of Higher Mathematics, Faculty of Economics, National Research University Higher School of Economics
02.2009 – 11.2009 Research associate, Laboratory "Methods of choice and analysis of decisions", Center for Fundamental Research, National Research University - Higher School of Economics.
02.2008 – 06.2010 Lecturer, Chair of Higher Mathematics, Department of Economics, National Research University - Higher School of Economics.
03.2002 – 06.2008 Instructor, "Initiative on Distance Learning" program, affiliated with Stanford Institute for International Studies and Stanford School of Education.
09.2006 – 01.2008 Head, Department of Overseas Internships, Center for Professional Development, State University - Higher School of Economics.
07.1999 – 08.2006 Lecturer, Chair of General Political Science, Department of Applied Political Science, State University - Higher School of Economics.
EXPERIENCE OF TEACHING WORK
Certified as a pedagogical trainer by Stanford School of Education.
Work in NRU HSE
Courses:
Calculus (for students majoring in Business Informatics);
Social Choice Theory (for students majoring in Economics, for students majoring in Computer Science);
Methods for analysis of political processes (for students majoring in Political Science);
Theory of Differential and Difference Equations (for students majoring in Economics);
Political Science (for students majoring in Law, for students majoring in Management, for students majoring in Philosophy);
Political Theory (for students majoring in Journalism);
Paradigms of Political Science (for students majoring in Political Science);
Logic of Science and Methodology of Political Research (for students majoring in Political Science);
Courses offered by Stanford University through the program “Initiative on Distance Learning” (organized by Stanford Institute for International Studies),
(seminars):
101 International Security in a Changing World
102 International Environmental Politics
103 Security, Civil Liberties and Terrorism
104 Major Issues in International Conflict Management
105 Democracy, Development and the Rule of Law
Work in Moscow State University (Lomonosov), Department of Physics
Courses:
Quantum Theory
Data for the 2012 on economic, management, and political science journals have been used to produce quantitative estimates of (in)consistency of evaluations based on seven popular bibliometric indicators. A new approach to the construction of aggregate journal rankings has been proposed: aggregation is considered to be a multi-criteria decision problem and to solve it ordinal ranking methods originated in social choice theory are employed. We applied both direct ranking methods based on majority rule (e.g. the Copeland rule, Markovian method) and the multistage procedure of selection and exclusion of the best journals, as determined by a majority rule-based social choice solution concept (tournament solution), such as the uncovered set and the minimal externally stable set. The same method of majority-rule-based binary comparisons has been used to analyze correlations of rankings. It has been demonstrated that aggregate rankings reduce the number of contradictions and represent the set of single-indicator-based rankings better than any of the these seven rankings themselves.
The Competitive Industrial Performance index (developed by experts of the UNIDO) has been considered. It is designed as a measure of national competitiveness. Index is an aggregate of eight observable variables, representing different dimensions of competitive industrial performance. Instead of using a cardinal aggregation function, what CIP’s authors do, it has been proposed to apply ordinal ranking methods borrowed from social choice: either direct ranking methods based on the majority relation (e.g. the Copeland rule, the Markovian method) or a multistage procedure of selection and exclusion of the best alternatives, as determined by a majority relation-based social choice solution concept (tournament solution), such as the uncovered set and the minimal externally stable set. The same method of binary comparisons based on the majority rule has been used to analyse rank correlations. It has been demonstrated that the ranking is robust but some of the new aggregate rankings represent the set of criteria better than the original ranking based on the CIP.
Academic interests
- Social and multi-criteria choice, cooperative and non-cooperative games, individual and collective decision making, spatial voting;
- Foundations of quantum theory, quantum games, quantum and quantum-like theories of decision-making
Lecture by Andrey Subochev on "Monkeys choose as if maximizing utility compatible with basic principles of revealed preference theory"
On Sunday, April 26 the scientific seminar of the International Centre of Decision Choice and Analysis was held. A. Subochev discussed the paper on "Monkeys choose as if maximizing utility compatible with basic principles of revealed preference theory" of Pastor-Bernier A., Plott C. R., Schultz W.
Autumn School "The modern methods and models of the individual and collective choice and decision-making theory with application to network data analysis, aggregation problems, influence indices" was held at DeCAn lab
On November 12-15, the Autumn school on modern methods and models of the individual and collective choice and decision-making theory with application to network data analysis, aggregation problems, influence indices was opened. The event is organized by the International Laboratory of Decision Choice and Analysis (DeCAn lab). Among the invited lecturers there are outstanding academics and researchers: Hans Peters (Maastricht University, Netherlands), Kanak Patel (Cambridge University, UK), Laszlo Koczy (Centre for Economic and Regional Studies, Hungary), Anna Khmelnitskaya (St Petersburg University, Russia), Peter Emerson (de Borda Institute, UK).
Autumn school "Current trends in decision-making analysis". Day 1
On November 7, the Autumn school on Current Trends in Decision-making Analysis opened. The event is organized by the International Laboratory of Decision Choice and Analysis. Among the invited lecturers there are outstanding academics and researchers: Itzhak Gilboa, Theocharis Grigoriadis, Michel Grabisch, Gabrielle Demange, Saptarshi Mukherjee, Stefan Napel, Agnieszka Rusinowska, William Thomson, and Katarína Cechlárová.
School "Decision making in network context" and International Workshop "The 7th Murat Sertel Workshop on Economic Design, Decision, Institutions, and Organization" were held at DeCAn lab
DeCAn lab organized two events which were held from September 25 to September 28 - a school "Decision making in network context" (September 25-26, 2017) and an international workshop "The 7th Murat Sertel Workshop on Economic Design, Decision, Institutions, and Organization" (September 27-28, 2017). DeCAn faculty took part in organizing and holding these events.