• A
  • A
  • A
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
Regular version of the site

From Ancient Inscriptions to Blogs: Different Disciplines’ View on Ego Texts

HSE has held its post-graduate humanities summer school 'History in the First Person: From Antiquity to Our Time'. The summer school was dedicated to texts written or recorded in the first person, as well as to various methods for analysing them. The school’s organizers and participants spoke with the HSE news service about what ego texts are, how representatives of different disciplines work with them, and how French methodology differs from Russian.

Oleg Voskoboynikov, historian, Tenured Professor at the Higher School of Economics

In the late 20th century the status of personal experience, and even discourse – abandoned by chance yet recorded by history – changed dramatically in the humanities. Figuratively speaking, history discovered direct speech, which is heard in ego-texts – correspondence, diaries, autobiographies, poetry, memoirs, confessions, denunciations and interrogations, interviews, notarial acts and memorial books from medieval monasteries. The carriers of such information, which range from ancient inscriptions to interviews and medieval manuscripts to blogs, are as diverse as the methods used to analyse them. The development of these methods over the past two decades has significantly enriched the dialogue with societies of the past and has opened up promising new avenues for research.

We conceived of the school with our Parisian friends Alain Blum and Larisa Zakharova in 2013 right after a cooperation agreement was signed between HSE and the School for Advanced Studies in the Social Sciences in Paris. We were later joined by Emilia Koustova of the University of Strasbourg, where there is a long tradition of Slavic Studies, and Hélène Mélat of the Centre of Franco-Russian Research in Moscow. As a result, HSE now has an excellent team of French specialists who have a strong knowledge of Russian culture and psychology. We have virtually no restrictions in terms of geography or period of history. The purpose of the school is to learn how an individual’s voice sounded and was recorded in texts throughout history – from antiquity to the present day – and what research strategies can and should be used by experts from different disciplines to identify this voice.

Historians, philologists, and philosophers ask different questions of both historical facts and the texts where they are recorded, but as it turns out during debates, they have quite a lot in common

The interdisciplinary nature of such a school is self-evident; one of its main tasks was to create conditions for professional conversation among researchers who come from different backgrounds, use different methodological tools, and take different approaches to the study of ego-documents.

As for historians, I am convinced that we need to constantly reflect on what historical fact is, how it is recorded, how we should analyse it, and what lies behind it. And the outside perspective is not the perspective of an historian but rather that of a participant in the events, which even if biased may help in seeing the different layers of reality behind one fact and one text. Historians, philologists, and philosophers ask different questions of both historical facts and the texts where they are recorded, but as it turns out during debates, they have quite a lot in common.

For example, when the writer Anna Berdichevskaya describes life in the Gulag, what is she describing in reality when she tells the story about her mother? After all, there are several stages of information processing between the reality of the Gulag and us, sitting in a classroom and listening to the report of a student who is taking an interview. First, it was the will of Berdichevskaya’s mother, her ability to express an idea, and her willingness or unwillingness to tell something. Her silence is also an historical fact. Second, it is her daughter’s thoughts on what she heard from her mother; the result of these thoughts is a recorded story. Third, there is the work that editors and proofreaders do with the printed version of this story. And fourth, there are the mind, heart and voice of our rapporteur who interviewed Berdichevskaya, and this voice of the researcher makes its transformation to the past.

At the school, we were able to bring 30 such voices to the classroom – 20 French and 10 Russian. Naturally, most of the reports were on the 20th century, but there were a few reports on antiquity, the Middle Ages, the Renaissance and the modern era. To some extent, I feel as though I am a French envoy to our university, and for me it was important that almost all of these voices were heard in French – a language with a rich intellectual tradition. I am convinced that the humanities will die if such national intellectual traditions that are entitled to their languages are lost.

 

Alain Blum, historian, demographer, Professor at the School for Advanced Studies in the Social Sciences (Paris)

We chose a theme that allows experts from different fields to find interesting topics for themselves. We have been cooperating with HSE for a long time, and I think that we already have a tradition of working together; this school has once again confirmed that we understand one another. We brought quite a few French students to the school, and the extent to which they could work here productively and in an intellectually enriching way (in many ways due to the fact that the school was French speaking) confirms that we have truly managed to establish cooperation.

 

Larisa Zakharova, historian, Professor at the School for Advanced Studies in the Social Sciences (Paris)

In French the name of this school – À la première personne, écritures de soi de l’Antiquité à l’époque contemporaine – sounded like ‘History of the First Person: From Antiquity to the Modern Day’, but I think it would be more precise to say ‘From the First Person: Ego-Texts from Antiquity to Our Time’. The second option better reflects our idea of holding an interdisciplinary gathering. With the peculiarities of translation, it seems that from the Russian side historians were the main ones to express interest in the conference, but from France there was a variety of disciplines – philosophers, historians, philologists, anthropologists, and linguists. However, in the end, we really managed to go beyond the disciplinary framework and show historians how ‘their’ object of research is seen by other scholars.

Over the course of the three days, we saw three approaches to the analysis of ego-history. The first can be called ‘demarcation’, which implies very clear disciplinary boundaries, with representatives speaking only from the perspective of their field and not showing particular interest in what is happening in other disciplines. The second approach is ‘integration’, when we are enticed by the idea of being ​​interdisciplinary, borrow approaches from other disciplines and apply them mechanically without thinking about the fact that this transfer involves an epistemological shift. The third approach is ‘conversationalism’ – a transfer of ideas and approaches developed in one discipline to another in which there is a correlation of methodologies and concepts of two fields. This approach is just beginning to appear at the school, but I am certain that it will be the starting point for something more substantial. 

 

Hélène Mélat, literary historian, Centre of Franco-Russian Research (Moscow)

I have been studying contemporary Russian prose for quite some time. It’s still a very interesting topic, as cultural life in Russia has remained dynamic. Although it’s not the same as it was in the 1990s, but still... Here you can feel how society is changing and how literature is changing with it. You can feel the drive for change that fuels culture, and how marginal art becomes mainstream.

As for the topic of the conference, my interest is related to the huge layer of ego-texts (memoirs, diaries, etc.) that are published in Russia. Today, everyone is ready to write something, for example, about how they lived in the 1990s. A separate discourse has been formed – a special type of writing about oneself. At its centre is an individual storyteller. Together with the multitude of specifics and descriptions of the smallest details of everyday life that seem to have no relation to big history, a picture of an era is emerging that you will never see in a textbook.

 

Irina Mastyaeva, 2nd year Master’s student, ‘Historical Knowledge’ programme

When philosophers start talking about the internal and external ‘I’ that is heard in a text, they do so quite unlike historians would. When literary historians work with memoirs or letters (what are called ego-texts or ego-documents today), it is obvious how they work in a different way and draw other conclusions. During these three days, I constantly felt the need for translation from the language of one discipline to that of another; this is the challenge and the essence of the school.

Since I study medieval France, I found an academic conference on the French language interesting. On the one hand, I saw it as an opportunity to practice the language in which I have to read much of the literature and write. On the other hand, it was an opportunity to once again admire the French academic methodology. When you read French studies, their three-part structure sinks in and becomes something native. Even my French teachers, who do not see themselves as fans of the French system, eventually return to it. They attribute this to the fact that their academic culture of thinking (and writing) goes back to Descartes, so they are systematic and logical. We have learned something from them, and I hope that we have also taught them something.

See also:

Underground Capitalist in Soviet Russia

Nikolai Pavlenko, a shadow entrepreneur and creator of a successful business in Stalin’s USSR, was executed by firing squad in 1955. Running a successful commercial enterprise right under the dictator’s nose in a strictly planned economy was a striking but not so uncommon case in the Soviet Union at the time, according to HSE professor Oleg Khlevniuk who made a number of unexpected findings having studied newly accessible archival documents. Below, IQ.HSE offers a summary of what his study reveals.

From Chains to Art Therapy: The Evolution of Mental Health Care

Mental health disorders are among the leading worldwide causes of disease and long-term disability. This issue has a long and painful history of gradual de-stigmatization of patients, coinciding with humanization of therapeutic approaches. What are the current trends in Russia regarding this issue and in what ways is it similar to and different from Western countries? IQ.HSE provides an overview of this problem based on research carried out by Svetlana Kolpakova.

Moscow to Paris: Here, There, and Everywhere

In early July, the fifth summer school organized by French association D’Est together with the HSE Vysokovsky Graduate School of Urbanism, with the support of the French Embassy in Russia and the Paris Mayor’s Office, was held in Paris. For 11 days, students of the HSE Master’s programme in Urban Development and Spatial Planning and members of Moscow’s Municipal Council learned about French urban development, local administration and the country’s participatory democracy.

What Does the Lens of Gender Reveal?

In June, faculty members from HSE’s School of Cultural Studies, the School of Philosophy, and the Poletayev Institute for Theoretical and Historical Studies in the Humanities met with colleagues from the University of Pittsburgh (USA) and a Russian art historian to participate in a round table on the importance of gender studies in the humanities. The researchers discussed questions such as what historians, philosophers, and historians can achieve when approaching their fields of study from the standpoint of gender studies, and what the state of gender studies is in contemporary Russia and abroad.

HSE First-Year Students Develop a Telegram Bot to Help the Homeless

This summer, university students from all over Russia took part in the Digital Transformation of the Charity Sector Summer School in Moscow. Students from HSE University and other universities presented digital solutions to make non-profit organizations more efficient and even save lives.

Introduction to Daurian Gothic: What It Is and How It Has Emerged in Transbaikalia

Medieval horror, vampires, sorcerers, mysterious monks and the rising dead, alongside real historical figures and stories about the Russian Civil War wrapped in the aura of mysticism – this is perhaps the shortest formula for Daurian Gothic. Alexei Mikhalev, Doctor of Political Science, discusses this phenomenon and its evolution.

Participants of Russian-Chinese Summer School on International Affairs Tackle Trade, International Institutions, and More

On Thursday, July 11, students and faculty of the International Russian-Chinese Summer School on International Affairs bid farewell with a festive awards ceremony and closing lecture by Professor Sergey Karaganov, Academic Supervisor and Dean of the Faculty of World Economy and International Affairs.

Russian Summer School on Institutional Analysis Wraps up 2019 Session

After a fruitful week of presentations, feedback, and critical reevaluation, the 2019 session of the Russian Summer School on Institutional Analysis (RSSIA) came to a close. Admission to this year's session was highly competitive: out of 100 applications, only 24 were accepted. Participants came from a wide range of countries, including China, Germany, India, Iran, and others, to take their research to the next level in an intimate setting.

Russian and French Scholars Present Research on Soviet History at Graduate Seminar

The International Centre for the History and Sociology of World War II and its Consequences at HSE University held a Graduate Student Seminar in Soviet History together with Sciences Po (France) on June 17 – 18, 2019. HSE News Service spoke with participants and instructors of the seminar, which examinedthe impact of WWII on the Soviet Union and surrounding regions, as well as aspects of the Soviet system from Stalin up to the 1980s.

In Search of Truth in the Pravda Newspaper

On June 24-25, HSE University held the international academic conference, ‘The 1990s: A Social History of Russia’ organized by International Center for the History and Sociology of World World War II and its Consequences, the Boris Yeltsin Center, the Egor Gaider Foundation, and the Friedrich Ebert Foundation. HSE News Service spoke with Roberto Rabbia, one of the international participants, about how he became interested in Soviet history, why he reads Soviet newspapers, and what he has learned from his research.