• A
  • A
  • A
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
Regular version of the site

‘There Is Something Inherently Interesting in People Who Break the Mainstream Norm’

‘There Is Something Inherently Interesting in People Who Break the Mainstream Norm’

© iStock

This December, HSE University’s Poletayev Institute for Theoretical and Historical Studies in the Humanities hosted Professor Juliane Fürst, from Leibniz Centre for Contemporary History, who gave a lecture about Soviet hippies and the Soviet Flower Power. In an interview with HSE News Service, Professor Fürst spoke about her interest in Soviet subcultures and her research plans.

Juliane Fürst

— Why did you start studying hippies?

— I think there is something inherently interesting in people who break the mainstream norm. It is a surprisingly difficult act to do. It also always precipitates major societal shifts, since the subculture itself might be small, its wider impact and ideological and normative legacy, however, lasts for many decades and engulfs many more people.

Hippies in both East and West are a case in point. Even if we assume tens of thousands of hippies, compared to conformist youth they were small in numbers. And yet everywhere they changed standards of fashion, behaviour, ethics and ideological outlook.

On a more personal level, I think, I simply like contrarians and anarchists—and subcultural types usually are contrarian and anarchist, even though—and that makes them even more interesting—they too quickly can become enforcers of their own inner homogeneity and authoritarian guardians of their style.

For a long time the main attraction of researching Soviet hippies was the reaction I first had, when I stumbled across a reference to them. I thought, 'really - there was such a thing as Soviet hippies?'

For many years that was the most frequent response I got from people when telling them about my project. It was fun to engage in work where one feels one is really putting something genuinely new on the table.

For me my work on and with hippies was hugely influential, because it taught me so many things: some personal, some pertaining to the nature of subcultures, some relating to people as such, and quite a bit about late socialism, globalisation and its limits, and contemporary Russia. The vast majority of my sources are interviews I conducted with over hundred former participants in the wider hippie scene.

This meant going to people's houses, sitting in their kitchens and drinking their tea and coffee. I did this not only in Russia but also in Ukraine, Lithuania, Latvia, Estonia, Israel, the USA and Germany

I think I stuck with the topic for so long not only because it turned out to be so much more complex than I first thought, but also because I had such an interesting time researching it. It was emotionally very intense, but endlessly rewarding.

— How did Soviet hippies differ from hippies in the West?

— It is impossible to answer this question in five sentences. To a certain extent, the entire 480 pages of my book, Flowers through Concrete: Explorations in the Soviet Hippieland and Beyond, are devoted to this question.

But just as a teaser: Soviet hippies had to be tougher and more devoted than Western hippies merely to exist

Yet they survived far longer as a movement than hippies in the USA or Western Europe. And they responded to state pressure in such a sophisticated way—not least with the creation of their own everyday reality—that rather than classifying them as antidotes to late socialism I label their relationship with the Soviet system symbiotic.

Nothing is more telling than the fact that the Soviet hippies called their own network of contacts, rituals and norms 'sistema'—a clear aping and manipulation of the 'big' Soviet system.

Soviet hippies wanted to be different, but de facto they became part and parcel of the complex fabric of late Soviet reality—with all its contradictions, defects and—yes— advantages

Life in the Soviet Union was cheap. Subcultures were not snuffed out by their commercialisation. There was always a convenient enemy in the form of the repressive state on hand—hence ensuring coherence in an anarchic movement whose members had often little more in common than their dislike of the sovok.

And yet, they constantly referred back to this Soviet reality—sometimes jokingly, sometimes earnestly. When the Soviet Union collapsed, the Soviet hippie sistema followed very quickly,

— Where are former hippies now?

— They are everywhere. They work in the presidential administration. They live in dingy flats on the outskirts of Moscow. They are travelling in India and Thailand. They are in Vilnius, Riga, Lviv, Jerusalem, and New York.

Almost everyone I interviewed insisted that they are still hippies, even though they often lead quite some bourgeois lives these days. What struck me was how welcomingly most of them received me and hope openly they spoke about their past.

I think I arrived just at the right time—not too close to events to make it feel threatening (even though some did tell me that I was a bit like a KGB agent asking them all these personal questions), and not too far away to make it all too late.

Juliane Fürst
Photo courtesy of Juliane Fürst

Even though for many people I did come too late. Many, many hippies died in the 1990s for a variety of reasons, and many more have died since I interviewed them. This is another reason this research always felt important.

The official documents are few and far in between and tell little about how the sistema really functioned. I was recovering voices before they disappeared forever

— What are your research plans?

— I am planning a history of Perestroika from below and from afar—meaning I would like to shift the narrative away from Gorbachev and from Moscow and Leningrad. I also want to extend the narrative away from the purely political and economical, but see Perestroika as a time of shifting norms and morals.

I am excited to see where this research will take me, but places on the Eastern side of the Soviet Union are on my travel list 

I am right now co-operating with Professor Maria Maiofis on a truly exciting project, which aims to write a comparative history of the Chinese and Russian revolutionary experiences. We are only two of the five members of an organizing committee, and the authorial team consists of over 20 people.

The project is very international, involving academics from all across the world. But HSE is home to many esteemed colleagues, so I hope that there will be more collaboration in future. 

See also:

‘I Have Always Respected the University’s Comprehensiveness and Inclusiveness’

Throughout July, students of the HSE International Summer University are studying Russian History and Behavioural Economics. The courses are taking place in an online format—something that seemed unthinkable for a summer programme before the COVID-19 pandemic. Recent years have shown that online learning is a unique opportunity for students from all over the world to study with leading HSE University professors from the comfort of their own homes.

Funny Pictures of Difficult Era

The first major Soviet publisher of children's literature, Raduga, was established a century ago and featured the debuts of many authors who would later go on to become famous, as well as illustrations by prominent artists. Based on a research paper by Marina Sazonenko, graduate of the HSE Doctoral School of Art and Design, IQ.HSE examines how — and why — the illustrations in Soviet periodicals for children changed over time.

‘Boundaries of History’ Seminar Starts New Season of Meetings

On September 30, Stephen Riegg, Assistant Professor of History of the Texas A&M University, presented his book Russia’s Entangled Embrace: The Tsarist Empire and the Armenians, 1801-1914 at the first seminar of this year’s Boundaries of History series.We spoke with Professor Alexander Semyonov, the seminar chair and the Director of the HSE Centre for Historical Research, about the goals of the seminar and to Stephen Riegg about his research.

European Values: From the Discovery of America to the First World War

The English-language course ‘Europe and the World, ca. 1500 to 1914’ has launched on Coursera. Its author, Andrey Iserov, Deputy Dean for International Affairs at the HSE Faculty of Humanities, examines a historical span of four centuries during which European states reached the peak of their economic, military, and political power. Students of the course will learn how the independence of Hispanic America by the mid-1820s influenced China, what caused the religious schism in Western Christianity in the 16th century, and how European colonial policy developed.

‘The Past Is Never Dead. It's Not Even Past’

This summer, the HSE Centre for the History and Sociology of World War II and Its Consequences was reorganized to become the HSE Institute for Advanced Soviet and Post-Soviet Studies. Oleg Budnitskii, Doctor of Historical Sciences, head of the Centre and director of the Institute, talked to the HSE News Service about the new division.

Exploring the History of Places and Environment in Russia

The collective volume Place and Nature: Essays in Russian Environmental History, co-edited by David Moon, Nicholas B. Breyfogle, and HSE researcher Alexandra Bekasova, was recently presented at a seminar of the Laboratory for the Environmental and Technological History of the Centre for Historical Research at HSE – St. Petersburg. The book is one of the fruits of a networking project carried out in 2013-2016 with active participation of HSE researchers.

Conference Brings Together New Perspectives on the Russian Far East

On March 28-31, 2021, the HSE International Laboratory ‘Russia’s Regions in Historical Perspective’ held an international conference ‘The Russian Far East: Regional and Transnational Perspectives (19th -21st cent.)’. The event was jointly organized by the Laboratory with the German Historical Institute Moscow, Indiana University Bloomington (USA), and the Institute of History, Archeology and Ethnography of the Peoples of the Far East FEB RAS (Vladivostok).

Studying the Middle Ages Is Fascinating

The recently launched Master's Programme in Medieval Studies is the only Master’s degree in Russia fully dedicated to medieval studies. HSE News Service spoke with Juan Sota, a second-year student of the programme, about its unique features, interacting with professors, and his research interests and aspirations.

British Scholar on Exploring Russian History

On February 9, the HSE International Laboratory 'Russia’s Regions in Historical Perspective' hosted Janet Hartley (London School of Economics), who presented her recent monograph The Volga: A History of Russia’s Greatest River. The presentation was part of a joint lecture series between the Laboratory and The Mikhail Prokhorov Foundation. HSE news service spoke with Janet Hartley about her interest in Russia, her experience travelling and doing research in Russia, and the books she has written on Russia.

Financial Front: The USSR State Budget during World War II

After June 1941, the Soviet budget was no longer the same. Marking the end of peaceful life, budget revenues dwindled, and the Treasury was drained of billions of rubles. But because the war required money, the government had to find it from somewhere. Oleg Khlevnyuk, Professor at the HSE University’s School of History, examines the Soviet Union’s wartime and post-war financial policies in his paper.