• A
  • A
  • A
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
Regular version of the site

Upcoming Neuroeconomics Symposium Aims to Share New Research and Build International Collaboration

Upcoming Neuroeconomics Symposium Aims to Share New Research and Build International Collaboration

© HSE University

On September 23-24, the CCCP19 Symposium ‘Cognition, Computation, Neuroeconomics and Performance’ will be held at HSE University. The goal of the symposium is to exhibit cutting edge research at the CCDM, a leading cognitive neuroscience research centre in Russia, and LNC2, a leading European research centre in neuroeconomics, cognitive neuroscience and neural theory. Ahead of CCCP19, the HSE News Service spoke with the conference organizer and several invited speakers about the plan for this symposium and the importance of their research in the field.

The event is a collaboration between the Centre for Cognition and Decision Making (CCDM) at the Higher School of Economics, the Laboratory for Cognitive and Computational Neuroscience (LNC2) at the HSE Institute for Cognitive Neuroscience (ICN) and the Laboratoire des Neurosciences Cognitives et Computationelles at the Department of Cognitive Studies, Ecole Normale Superieure (Paris, France). CCCP19 follows a tradition of CCCP conferences that have taken place annually over the past six years.

This year’s focus, neuroeconomics, is a burgeoning field that aims to combine the methods of economics, behavioural economics and neuroscience to understand the basis of human economic behaviour. Research in neuroeconomics uses a wide variety of modern methods, including computational modelling, non-invasive brain stimulation, and functional imaging.

This is the first seminar on neuroeconomics to be held jointly with École Normale Supérieure (ENS). How did this scientific partnership develop?

Vasilisa Skvortsova (Organizer, Post-doctoral fellow at the Ecole Normale Supérieure, PSL University, Paris, France): Although the partnership between ENS and CCDM started several years ago, this seminar extends this collaboration by inviting new team leaders and young LNC2 and CCDM members (PhD students and post-doctoral fellows) to present their work on decision-making and neuroeconomics. When I visited the CCDM last year, I realized that there are a lot of intersection points between research at the CCDM and at the LNC2 but that there is a lack of knowledge sharing, particularly among young researchers. This is where the idea of this year symposium was born.

Valentin Wyart (Invited speaker, Inserm, Ecole Normale Supérieure, PSL University, Paris, France): Grounding neuroeconomics in existing theories of human cognition is a direction that could foster its development in my opinion. A large share of research in neuroeconomics relies on purely behavioural economics-based theories and ignores very relevant knowledge about attention, learning, memory and decision-making beyond economics that has been gathered in cognitive psychology and neuroscience over the past several decades. I would be very interested in discussing the possible ways by which neuroeconomics researchers could inform their theoretical models and experimental paradigms using research in human cognition.

What is most relevant today in the development and study of neuroeconomics?

Vasilisa: I see the key points of the discussion centred on how we make our decisions and learn in complex environments and what the possible neurobiological origins of these decisions are. The complexity of the environment comes in different forms. It could be its volatility – the unexpected changes that the agent has to adapt to. It could also be a social or informational context, for example, the number of options given to choose from or the type of alternative proposed. Finally, it could come from the complexity of the internal beliefs of the decision-maker, for example, holding conflicting beliefs that must be resolved before making a decision). 

At the methodological level, it would be very interesting to see how each of the groups could use the methodology of the other in their research. For instance, how trans-cranial magnetic stimulation – where Vasily Klucharev and his group are true experts – could be used to study decision variability in the task proposed by Stefano and Valentin or by applying new mathematical models to study cognition.   

Stefano Palminteri (Invited speaker, Inserm, Ecole Normale Supérieure, PSL University, Paris, France): One of the important fields in neuroeconomics is to understand cognitive biases. What we call cognitive bias is a systematic deviation from rationality or normative judgement. Economists assume that an agent makes her choices rationally. However, in reality, humans are far from being rational. For example,  it is well known that a lot of individuals are risk-averse: between a risky gamble and a certain option, many individuals will choose a certain option even if its expected value is lower than the expected value of the gamble. I’m interested in other types of cognitive biases, namely, how the context in which we have to make a choice changes the valuation process. For example, if you are in Italy, you might be very picky when choosing where to take your coffee and you will value a cup of coffee from a vending machine very little. However, if you are driving at night in the middle of the forest and are feeling sleepy, this cup of coffee will be of very high value.

This relative valuation process is present not only in humans but in other species. I’m particularly interested in the neurocomputational mechanics of this relative valuation process. For example, I found that choosing from experience (by trial and error as all animals do) is different from choosing from description (like in most of the economic tasks in humans) and the relative evaluation process differs.

What are your research interests in neuroeconomics?

Valentin: I think that understanding the computations governing economic choices requires understanding the sources of decision inconsistency. In other words, why do people choose differently in the same circumstances – not only in everyday life but also in controlled conditions in the laboratory.

My current research investigates the contribution of different sources of decision inconsistency under uncertainty. In contrast to existing theories that explain human inconsistencies in terms of an exploration-exploitation trade-off, my group has recently shown that most inconsistencies arise from the limited precision of reinforcement learning in the human brain. Understanding the sources of decision inconsistencies is also crucial beyond neuroeconomics for clinicians - to characterize disorders of decision-making in psychiatric conditions such as obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) or attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).

Stefano: The field of neuroeconomics, although relatively recent, is nonetheless quite vast. This is a truly interdisciplinary field as it attracts attention from researchers in neuroscience, cognition, machine learning and economics. I am particularly interested in the computational cognitive neuroscience part where we try to provide mechanistic models of decision-making (in contrast to normative or descriptive models). This means that we’ll be able to trace all the steps that lead to a decision in the way it happens in real life. 

Beyond exhibiting new research, the event also aims to foster further collaboration between CCDM and LNC2. Significant links between these two centres of excellence already exist. For example, Boris Gutkin, a team leader at LNC2, is also a leading scientist at CCDM where he has directed the Neural Theory Group for the past six years; Etienne Koechlin, head of LNC2, is a member of the Institute for Cognitive Neuroscience (ICN) and the CDM Advisory Council. Additionally, several joint doctoral projects are in the development. Recently, a new ERASMUS+ network project to develop curricula in cognitive neuroscience has been approved; Boris Gutkin is the coordinator of the project, and CCDM-ICN-HSE is a major partner.


See also:

‘No One Expected Online Education to Receive Such a Powerful Impetus for Further Development’

On March 17, the Institute of Education hosted its annual seminar dedicated to issues in education. This year’s seminar addressed the topic, ‘Higher Education during an Epidemic: The Possibilities of Digital Technology’. For the first time in eight years, the seminar participants—representatives of Chinese, American, and Russian universities—participated in the event remotely.

Discovering Russia from the Inside and Out

At the end of February, the HSE IGITI Research Centre for Contemporary Culture hosted a roundtable entitled ‘Field Studies in Russia: A Country Familiar and Foreign’. Roundtable participants talked about field work methods and standards, research challenges, and ways to solve them. The participants also discussed the extent to which it is possible to apply international experiences and approaches to field work in Russia as well as ways to study Russia from within and without.

HSE University and United Nations Volunteer Programme Sign Cooperation Agreement

HSE University, represented by the Center for Studies of Civil Society and the Nonprofit Sector, and the United Nations Volunteer Programme (UNV) signed a partnership agreement, under which they will regularly exchange information, carry out joint research, as well as organize conferences and other events.

Attention and Atención: How Language Proficiency Correlates with Cognitive Skills

An international team of researchers carried out an experiment at HSE University demonstrating that knowledge of several languages can improve the performance of the human brain. In their study, they registered a correlation between participants’ cognitive control and their proficiency in a second language.

Ambassadors and Embassy Representatives Gather for HSE University Day for Diplomatic Missions

On December 12, heads of missions and embassy representatives from over forty countries gathered in Moscow for HSE University Day for Diplomatic Missions. The event, which was held at HSE’s newly renovated Pokrovka campus, was aimed at fostering further cooperation between HSE and its international partners.

‘Today Is a Wonderful Day, Because I Hear Persian Being Spoken’

The Institute for Oriental and Classical Studies of the Faculty of Humanities has launched a Center of Iranian Studies and the Persian Language. On December 6, representatives of HSE University and the Cultural Representative of the Embassy of the Islamic Republic of Iran in Moscow signed the cooperation agreement.

‘Developing Asian and Area Studies is a Huge Priority for the Next Decade’

Researchers and diplomats from 35 countries and eight Russian regional universities gathered at HSE University to discuss globalization in Asia and how it differs from what is taking place in Europe.

Two HSE Projects Win ‘Mega-Grant’ Competition

A ‘Mega-Grant’ Competition for ground-breaking research projects funded by the Russian Ministry of Science and Higher Education was held for the seventh time, and this year’s competition winners included two projects that will be based at HSE University campuses. One research group will study dynamic systems at HSE – Nizhny Novgorod, and a new social neurobiology laboratory will begin work at HSE University in Moscow.

'We Are Well in Line with the Data Science Trend in Finance'

On October 25-26, the International College of Economics and Finance (ICEF) and the Laboratory of Financial Economics (LFE) hosted the Eighth International Moscow Finance Conference at HSE University. This year’s programme included researchers from the University of California, Los Angeles; University of California, Berkeley; University of Warwick; University of Lausanne; and the London School of Economics. Their presentations dealt with a wide range of timely topics, including the forecasting potential of data science models.

‘Our Performance Is Only the Beginning’

Students of the HSE and University of London Parallel Degree Programme in International Relations earned some of the highest scores worldwide on the exams that the University of London administers at its foreign partner universities.