First Ever Monument to Anonymous Peer Reviewer Unveiled at HSE
The concrete block in the courtyard of the HSE Institute of Education has been a lasting image of the WW2 era. However, last summer, the institute’s staff came up with the idea of turning it into a piece of art. The idea was put forth by Igor Chirikov, Director of the Centre of Sociology of Higher Education, whereby this useless piece of concrete would be transformed into a monument to the ‘anonymous peer reviewer’. Moreover, this idea ended up garnering the most support as a result of an internal vote.
‘Peer reviewing is a matter of love and hate,’ said Igor Chirikov, noting: ‘Many of our colleagues have had the painful experience of getting negative reviews for their papers. And this is not the most pleasant part of academic life. At the same time, a reviewer’s work, which is often undervalued and unrewarding, is nevertheless an important tool for research development, which makes us sure that our results are precise, incontestable, and not accidental. So, when I was thinking about what the monument could be, I wanted to emphasize reviewers’ impact on research, on one hand, but to do this with a bit of irony, on the other hand, so as to motivate researchers who don’t always get positive reviews of their papers.’
The monument’s installation was a success thanks to a crowd-funding campaign, which attracted researchers from all over the world. For instance, the project was supported by two Nobel Prize winners. Eric Maskin, 2007 Nobel Laureate in Economics, called anonymous researchers the ‘unsung heroes of science’ who do invisible work ‘out of a sense of responsibility’. Furthermore, Andre Geim, 2010 Nobel Laureate in Physics, described reviewers’ contributions to scientific progress with the Latin phrase: ‘Dubito ergo sum’ (‘I doubt, therefore I am’).
‘Experts bear heavy responsible for their work; they are responsible for the further progression of certain research and educational areas. I believe it is very important to respect the work of such experts,’ said Liudmila Ogorodova, Deputy Minister of Education and Science of the Russian Federation, at the opening ceremony.
The monument to anonymous peer reviewers is represented by a big 1.5-tonne dice with sides featuring some of the opinions reviewers typically give to academic articles, such as ‘Accept’, ‘Minor Changes’, etc. The outlines of each cube side feature the titles of papers by researchers who contributed to monument (donated $60 and more). According to Igor Chirikov, it was decided by a coin toss as to whose paper would appear on which side.
Yaroslav Kuzminov, HSE Rector, spoke at the opening ceremony about being able to laugh, or ‘at least to smile at yourself’, which is an essential quality for any researcher. ‘We are living in a transitional time, when science is becoming truly global. The demands on the academic community are very high today. We can either keep on self-chastising and lamenting about how hard it is, or we can smile and go forward. We are definitely on the side of the second option,’ he stressed.
The monument’s opening ceremony was held in a completely informal atmosphere. Moreover, guests showed their support for the idea of reviewer ‘anonymity’ and wore masks at the event. At the end of the unveiling, Igor Chirikov urged everyone who might be expecting a reviewer’s verdict to rub the upper side of the monument ‘for luck’, while also saying the word ‘accept’ aloud. Hopefully, this will become a new HSE tradition.
The opening of the monument generated considerable interest in Russian and in international media - Nature, The Guardian, The Economist, University World News, Times Higher Education, Chemistry World and other media outlets wrote about this event.
Alexey Rutkevich, Doctor of Philosophy, Professor at the School of Philosophy at the Faculty of Humanities, Dean of the Faculty of Humanities, spoke on his foray into science, research interests, as well as shared his thoughts on a philosopher’s position in society.
Fuad Aleskerov, Tenured Professor and Head of the Department of Mathematics of the Faculty of Economics, Head of the International Laboratory of Decision Choice and Analysis, Chief Scientist at the Laboratory for Experimental and Behavioral Economics, member of the Academic Council, spoke on his foray into science, as well as shared his thoughts on the development of HSE and mathematics in Russia.
On November 27, HSE celebrated its 25th birthday with Anniversary Night (because an average birthday party would have been rather dull). The celebration featured an entire array of different activities, and HSE students themselves came up with the evening’s programme. Anniversary Night began with the finale of the Research Battles, and from 8:00 p.m. onward, the grand ‘Night’ festival by Ingroup CTC continued. To see and read more about how the event went, take a look at our coverage (photographs to be updated).
Maria Yudkevich, Vice Rector, Director of the Institute for Institutional Research, Associate Professor in the Faculty of Economic Sciences, Head of the International Research Laboratory for Institutional Analysis of Economic Reforms, and member of the HSE Academic Council, spoke on her path towards academia, research projects and achievements, as well as shared her thoughts on HSE research development.
The results of the 'Steal the Wheel’ Competition have been decided. Entrants suggested implementing some useful practices at HSE that had proved their efficiency at other Russian or international universities, with the winners receiving their prizes at the beginning of December. The winning projects include new approaches to writing theses, organising space in classrooms, and submitting reports on academic trips.
Oleg Ananyin, Tenured Professor, Professor in the Department of Theoretical Economics (Faculty of Economic Sciences), Academic Supervisor of the ‘Politics. Economics. Philosophy’ master’s programme, Chairman of the Education and Teaching Methods Council, Member of the HSE Academic Council, spoke on his academic interests, as well as shared his thoughts on the development of HSE and Russian economic community.
This exhibition has become part of the Open University project and is held on the HSE’s Anti-versary. It covers the history of Khitrovka and its surroundings, and offers a historical view of each object.
According to the decision of Sergey Sobyanin, Mayor of Moscow, fourteen HSE staff members were officially recognised by Moscow Government, with the awards being timed to coincide with the 25th anniversary of the university.
Evgeny Yasin, HSE Academic Supervisor, Tenured Professor, PhD in Economics, Professor in the Faculty of Economics, Academic Council member, and Academic Supervisor of the Expert Institute spoke on his scientific interests, research projects and achievements, as well as shared his thoughts on HSE research development.
Today is the sixth time HSE has been celebrating HSE Day at Gorky Park. Open air lectures, science and technology platform, sport master classes, intellectual competitions and many more activities are open for everyone. If you are not in the park now, follow our live broadcast on the website. And don’t hesitate to join the celebration any moment!