HSE Researchers Compare Performance in Mathematics for Children Starting School in Russia, Scotland and England
Researchers from the HSE Institute of Education have adapted and begun using an assessment tool for comparing the knowledge and skills of children starting school. Their first results were obtained from a sample of children starting school in Russia and the UK.
Researchers from the Higher School of Economics and the University of Durham made their first attempt at a cross-country comparison of first-grade performance in 2014. The purpose was, first, to check whether iPIPS (The International Performance Indicators in Primary Schools) can be used to compare the degree of preparedness for primary schools across different countries (England, Scotland and Russia), and second, to compare student progress after their first year in primary school despite differences in age, culture and educational practices of these countries.
The study featured here was exploratory and used a limited sample, including 300 subjects in Russia. The study findings have been published in Assessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice.
The researchers measured the country samples on the same metric scale and compared first-grader performance in mathematics in Russia, England and Scotland using an adapted iPIPS tool.
The researchers note that Russia is the first non-English speaking country to conduct a full comparative study using iPIPS with a representative sample, following a series of adaptation procedures and psychometric studies. "In this paper, we describe the instrument and confirm our hypothesis that an international comparative assessment of primary school children is possible," according to the authors.
In constructing international comparative study instruments, a common concern is their applicability to different cultures, since assessments created for measuring certain results in one culture are not necessarily capable of measuring the same results in a different culture. A specific challenge in adapting iPIPS was the different age of children starting school in different countries. In the UK, most children start school at 4 to 5 (tending towards four in England and five in Scotland), while in Russia, on average, children start school at seven (7.3 in the study sample).
The researchers thus adapted the original instrument for Russia by removing some of the more basic assignments and replacing them by those appropriate for seven-year-olds. Some other assignments were left intact and these later enabled a comparison of children's performance in mathematics at the baseline and after one year of primary school. The core 20 assignments of the total 70 performed by children in England, Scotland and Russia were the same for all groups.
'We used a special approach to recording and processing those assignments which tend to be easier for Russian or British children of similar abilities. For instance, Russian children, just because they are older, have a better knowledge of two-digit and three-digit numbers, while English children tend to perform better in logical problems. Treating these results equally across groups would have been unfair, because some children may perform well just by virtue of being from Russia or from Scotland. Therefore, we treated such assignments separately for children from different countries,' the study authors explain.
Since children in Russia start school later, they usually know much more: at the start, they are virtually at the level that English and Scottish children have attained by the end of their first school year. However, Russian children's increase in performance after the first year is less than that of the Scots. According to the researchers, a possible explanation is that younger children tend to learn new things faster.
'This study is unique in terms of being the first international study of children enabling a comparison of preparedness for school, in particular basic skills in mathematics, for children starting school in different countries. Second, we use a very reliable and valid instrument – iPIPS, which has been applied worldwide for nearly 20 years to assess more than 2 million children. And third, this study may be helpful in answering the question of at what age children should start school," according to Elena Kardanova, the study author and director of the HSE Institute of Education Centre for Education Quality Monitoring. "We plan to reassess the children we surveyed two years ago, in the spring of 2017, when they finish their third year, and then again in the spring of 2018. As a result, we can generate a substantial evidence base for assessment and comparison of student performance over the entire period of primary school.'
Children from undereducated, low-income families face a greater risk of poor academic performance. But schools are capable of decreasing these risks. Experts from the Center of Social and Economic School Development at the HSE Institute of Education have studiedinternational experience in addressing these challenges.
At a seminar held at HSE as part of the Days of the International Academy of Education in Moscow, Professor Gustavo E. Fishman (University of Arizona) likened international comparative studies of education quality to horse racing and discussed how these studies do not have as significant an impact on educational policy as is commonly believed.
According to a report by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) entitled Measuring Innovation in Education 2019: What Has Changed in the Classroom?, Russia ranked among the top three countries where schools are changing most rapidly.
The Institute of Education at HSE has signed an agreement outlining collaboration with the online platform, GlobalLab - a community of teachers and students who work on joint research projects over the Internet.
On April 14, 2017, Andreas Schleicher, Director for the Directorate of Education and Skills at OECD, spoke at the XVIII April Conference at Higher School of Economics (HSE). In 1999, he invented the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA), one of the biggest international comparative studies of education quality. His honorary lecture was dedicated to global trends in the transformation of national education systems.
It’s More Useful to Compare Students from Different Regions of a Single Country than from Different Countries
Professor Martin Carnoy of Stanford University and visiting professor at the Higher School of Economics, and Tatiana Khavenson, Research Fellow at the HSE Institute of Education, were among the authors of the report ‘An Analysis of the Impact of Education Policies on Student Achievement in the United States’, which was recently presented in Washington, DC. The key provisions of this report are of use when it comes to analyzing the situation in Russian education.
On October 28, the HSE Institute of Education seminar discussed international comparative research project – iPIPS (The International Performance Indicators in Primary Schools). It examines child development on enrolling in school and during their first year of studies. The research was carried out in the UK, and HSE Institute of Education specialists adapted it – and for the first time carried it out in Russia.