• A
  • A
  • A
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
Regular version of the site

Thinking Conceptually, Analyzing Empirically: The New Europe Barometer

On November 17th, 2011, Richard Rose, Director of the Centre for the Study of Public Policy and 6th Century Chair in Politics (University of Aberdeen) gave a talk on 'Thinking Conceptually, Analyzing Empirically: The New Europe Barometer' at the HSE Laboratory for Comparative Social Research (LCSR) in Saint Petersburg.

The main point of Richard Rose’s talk was the importance of asking meaningful questions. In his presentation he referred to the “Verstehen” sociology of Max Weber. According to Rose, it is very important to understand which concepts we are trying to study with quantitative data.

Richard Rose began his research in 1991 when many countries were suffering from the collapse of institutions. Most of the states he was studying had not existed 10 years before. People had to survive without any functioning institutions. There was a transformation taking place in politics (parties instead of the Party), economy (from planned to free market exchange), and society (the emergence of informal social capital).

The main focus of his work was to study the mass response to multidimensional institutional transformation. When conducting international comparisons, Rose claims, it should always be taken into account that in various countries, different questions matter. Some people assume that it is possible to ask the same questions in all countries. For example, surveys by the UN, IMF and the WVS sometimes extend questions to countries where there are no comparable institutions.

Richard Rose demonstrated some alternatives for conducting questionnaires. The main idea of his concept is not to ask people who are experiencing transformation questions which are pointless from their point of view but rather to listen to what they say. For example, Rose discussed his questionnaire with Bulgarians in 1991. They found many questions pointless and told stories from their life instead. So he tried to turn an anthropological ethnographic description into quantitative data, and this turned out to be possible to some extent.
Rose showed three examples of turning real life stories into quantitative data. These are micro-economic model, political evaluation and social capital.

Microeconomic model. Richard Rose compared the percentage of those whose income from their main job or pension is enough for living, and those who manage to cope with a multiplicity of resources. Unsurprisingly, the second group is larger in all transition countries. There is a huge difference in income level (from 61% in Slovenia to 15% in Russia), whereas the discrepancy in coping is much smaller (from 65% in Belorussia to 85% in Latvia).

Political evaluation. Instead of asking about democracy, Richard Rose asked about the regime, then about the idea of democracy, about freedoms which are reflected in behavior, etc. In the WVS 85% of Azerbaijan as satisfied with the level of democracy. He asked the audience how this statistical fact can be interpreted.

Furthermore he used Churchill’s hypothesis and asked about the other forms of government (military rule, a return to communist rule, suspension of parliament, elections, dictatorship). According to the results, a significant minority support alternative regimes.

Social capital. Richard Rose brought up the question of whether people trust a corrupt regime. He strongly believes that people have a portfolio of alternatives. The dimensions of social capital include the allocation of public sector by law, the allocation of the market to paying customers, non-monetized production, the begging or cajoling of officials controlling allocation, re-allocation in contravention of the rules etc.

After the presentation Ronald Inglehart and Christian Welzel discussed the issue of democracy. They demonstrated that the WVS also takes into consideration specific characteristics of different countries. Professor Inglehart noted that the understanding of democracy is very different and the WVS looks into what people think about democracy. For instance, people in Albania and Azerbaijan tend to have a higher opinion of democracy than people in Sweden and Switzerland. Christian Welzel mentioned that according to WVS, the support of democracy is very high even in societies which are not democratic in a European sense.

Further information can be found on Richard Rose’s website in the barometer section.

Download the presentation paper.

See also:

Caring for Loved Ones Motivated Young People to Wear Masks and Wash Their Hands More Often during Pandemic

Researchers from the HSE University in St Petersburg have found out what motivated young people to comply with the recommended quarantine measures during the pandemic. It turned out that willingness to protect their loved ones had the greatest effect on their behaviour. At the same time, fear of fines for not wearing masks and gloves in public places did not affect behavior in any way. The results of the study were published in the International Journal of Adolescence and Youth.

'We Are Seeking to Translate Research into Policy Solutions'

Social Policy for Sustainable Development and Inclusive Economic Growth is one of HSE University's strategic projects. The project is aimed at translating scientific achievements into practical solutions for social and economic policy. HSE researchers and their partners have been actively involved in this work, and the first results have been obtained. In her interview with the HSE News Service, Vice Rector Lilia Ovcharova, Academic Supervisor of the project, spoke about what has been done so far.

‘Uncertainty Transforms the Social Protection System into a Safety Cushion’

As part of the XXIII Yasin (April) International Academic Conference, HSE University held a meeting between HSE scholars and Anton Kotyakov, Minister of Labour and Social Protection of the Russian Federation. The title of the meeting was ‘The Future of Social Security: Trends and Forecasts.’ The experts and the Minister discussed the experience and lessons learned from population support initiatives during the pandemic, social protection efforts to reduce poverty and inequality, measures to counter sanctions, and the situation in the labour market.

Universal Basic Income: ‘This Is the Golden Dream of Artistic Bohemians’

The book ‘Exploring Universal Basic Income. A Guide to Navigating Concepts, Evidence, and Practices’ was presented at an HSE University event, which was organized by the HSE Institute of Social Policy. During the event, participants noted the foundational nature of the publication prepared by the World Bank experts and held an emotional debate on the prospects of introducing a universal basic income.

HSE University Scholars Discuss the Fight Against Poverty

HSE University hosted a Russian-Chinese meeting on ‘Social policy as a tool for combating poverty and developing human capital’. Representatives of the Chinese Ministry of Civil Affairs, the World Bank, the Russian Pension Fund, the government of Tatarstan, and HSE University researchers evaluated the social policies of both countries, shared effective measures for combating and eliminating poverty.

‘The President is Focused on Increasing the Birth Rate and Reducing Poverty by Half’

National objectives for social development, as well as existing risks and opportunities in implementing these objectives were discussed by participants of HSE International April Conference.

Russia Has the Resources for a Budget Manoeuvre That Helps Education, Healthcare, and Social Welfare

Issues concerning changes pertinent to key social spheres were discussed during the ‘Human Capital and Social Policy’ plenary session of the XIX April International Academic Conference on Economic and Social Development.

‘Information about the School is Passed from Generation to Generation’

From July 2 – 7, 2016, the 10th Russian Summer School on Institutional Analysis (RSSIA) took place just outside of Moscow. This event traditionally attracts experts in various areas of institutional research, as well as young researchers, for whom the School is a chance to work on projects under the supervision of leading scholars.

The Book Market, Finance and Reasons for Self-Medication: What People are Studying at the Summer School on Institutional Analysis

In the Moscow Region, the ninth Russian Summer School on Institutional Analysis (RSSIA) was held recently, bringing together 26 young researchers from Italy, Montenegro, the Philippines, Macedonia, Great Britain, Japan, Kyrgyzstan, Kazakhstan and Russia. During the programme, they addressed problems concerning the economics of education, financial institutions, the public sector, and the theory of industrial markets.

Human Capital Quality Delivers Economic Boost

In an environment where the natural-resources growth model is exhausted, human capital becomes the Russian economy's key competitive advantage. The problem of how the state, business and citizens can develop and invest in it was the main theme for the plenary discussion 'Social Policy Priorities' which took place on 7 April at the HSE's XVI April International Confernce on Modernizing the Economy and Society.