Where Is the Truth in Post-Truth Time?
On June 3-4, a conference entitled ‘Beyond Post-Truth: Media Landscapes in the “Age of Insecurity”’ was held in St. Petersburg. The conference was jointly organized by the Poletayev Institute for Theoretical and Historical Studies in the Humanities (IGITI) at HSE University, the Leibniz Institute for the History and Culture of Eastern Europe at GWZO Leipzig, the Max Weber Center for Advanced Cultural and Social Studies at the University of Erfurt, and Justus-Liebig-University Giessen.
The HSE News Service spoke with the organizers and participants about the main ideas and goals of the conference, including Daria Petushkova, postgraduate of School of Philosophy at HSE; Jan Surman, Research Fellow at the Poletayev Institute for Theoretical and Historical Studies in the Humanities; and Prof. Dr. Andreas Langenohl of the Institute for Sociology atJustus-Liebig-Universität in Germany.
The idea behind the post-truth conference
‘The idea for the conference actually came from a Facebook post – when we were holding a conference entitled “A New Culture of Truth? On the Transformation of Political Epistemologies since the 1960s” in Erfurt. Daria noted that it would be nice to hold it in Russia as well – and so we did,’ says Jan Surman. ‘But in fact, there are several continuities here. We are working with colleagues in Erfurt and Leipzig on an ongoing project about political epistemologies, which is increasingly becoming an investigation of the most recent transformations of political-philosophical concepts. In Moscow, Daria and I have a project called “Cultures of Critique” that involves critical investigation of the present time. So “post-truth” is just a stone’s throw from it.’
As Jan Surman stated, if you live in France or Russia, post-truth is omnipresent. People mostly use it in a way that implies that there is something as a past truth that was governing our lives, often in connection with security provided by the media and science. Clearly, this bygone era did not exist; it is more a myth, a kind of false security of a possibility that we could return to a time of strict division between truths and lies, to a time when people allegedly knew what was right and wrong. Clearly, much has changed in recent years in the political, social and media landscape, but using ‘post-truth’ or ‘fake news’ uncritically does not make us understand what the change is and where it happens.
‘So while we use post-truth in the title,’ says Jan Surman, ‘our conference in fact aimed to establish new ways of talking about the phenomenon of informational insecurity but also to better understand the mechanisms behind the “merchants of doubt” to allude to a recent book by Naomi Oreskes and Eric Conway.’
Research on post-truth is actually at a moment when scholarly interest and social interest are coming together and growing apart simultaneously.
Jan Surman proposed:
‘In fact, when we started the conference in Erfurt that I mentioned above, we started from the critique of “science marches”: clearly, there are institutions trying to discredit scientific research, but these marches brought back science as an instance of absolute truth, which is problematic, especially from the point of view of historians or sociologists who have put considerable effort in recent decades to demonstrate that science and knowledge are always “situated” and dependent on many local factors. Thus, there is a tension between the societal need for security and of instances providing it, and researchers showing that the basis of this security is not “strong” and cannot remain unquestioned.
So now, the intention behind our conference is not to deny the fact that there are institutions spreading “fake news” or lies, but rather to look at which mechanisms make people believe in different truths and accept them. As strange as it might seem, our proposal for societal security is accepting that there are no instances in which absolute certainty is provided.’
Word of the year for 2016
In 2016, the Oxford English Dictionary named ‘post-truth’ the word of the year. The term is defined as ‘denoting circumstances in which objective facts are less influential in shaping public opinion than appeals to emotion and personal belief.’
Daria Petushkova continued:
‘We are told by experts that in the post-truth era we are facing the problem of emotions replacing facts and falsehoods replacing news. Political observers state that “we have entered a post-truth era and that there is no coming back” but what does it actually mean? The prefix ‘post’ signals explicitly that ‘truth’ seems to be no longer relevant.
The analysis Hannah Arendt provided more than five decades ago in ‘Truth and Politics’ becomes crucial in these circumstances. She argued that ‘the result of a consistent and total substitution of lies for factual truth is not that the lies will now be accepted as truth, and the truth be defamed as lies, but that the sense by which we take our bearings in the real world – and the category of truth vs. falsehood is among the mental means to this end – is being destroyed.’
So how should we actually be dealing with the rise of this ‘new sensibility’, which treats emotional reactions and personal opinions higher than strong evidence and credible information?
One of the main aims of our conference was to embrace the spectrum of the questions that derive from the current ‘post-truth situation’ with a special focus on its specific vagueness.
Post-normativity should replace post-truth
Prof. Dr. Andreas Langenohl of theInstitute for Sociology at Justus-Liebig-Universität added that post-truth refers to a widespread sentiment that political communication, and political culture, have lost a fundamental normative orientation towards the truth, as opposed to lies.
He undertook conceptual research study in order to point out that ‘post-truth’ might be an inadequate term to describe current transformations taking place in the political and public sphere.
‘We should consider replacing the notion of “post-truth” with that of “post-normativity” which, to my mind, better captures a situation in which political messages are often reduced to the question of truth or lie,’ he shared as the main message of his report at the conference.
Participants of Russian-Chinese Summer School on International Affairs Tackle Trade, International Institutions, and More
On Thursday, July 11, students and faculty of the International Russian-Chinese Summer School on International Affairs bid farewell with a festive awards ceremony and closing lecture by Professor Sergey Karaganov, Academic Supervisor and Dean of the Faculty of World Economy and International Affairs.
The ninth annual international conference The Future of Education, held in Florence, Italy, brought together over 200 education researchers and professionals from 48 countries. Undergraduate students from HSE University were the only undergraduate students at the conference to present a paper.
One of the perks of studying at HSE University is its wide range of academic mobility programmes. Ksenia Semykina, a master’s student of Comparative Social Research, recently spent a semester at the Free University of Berlin with the support of an Erasmus+ scholarship. She shared some practical advice on how to live and study abroad with HSE News Service.
HSE University and the United Nations Human Settlements Programme signed an agreement to conduct joint research on urban development. HSE Rector Yaroslav Kuzminov and UN Under-Secretary-General Maimunah Mohd Sharif, who heads the UN-Habitat programme, signed the letter of intent at the recent Moscow Urban Forum, which was held on July 4-7 at Moscow’s Zaryadye Park.
Students who have been accepted to the HSE bachelor’s programmes in ‘Law’ and ‘Private Law’ may simultaneously enroll in the second degree programme at the University of London to supplement their basic training. The second degree programme is also open to external students and working professionals.
On June 24 – 28, HSE University – St. Petersburg hosted the International University Startups & Spin-Offs Festival (HSE Fest), which brings together students from across the world to pitch their startups for a one-time chance to win grants that will help them take their projects to the next level.
The International Centre for the History and Sociology of World War II and its Consequences at HSE University held a Graduate Student Seminar in Soviet History together with Sciences Po (France) on June 17 – 18, 2019. HSE News Service spoke with participants and instructors of the seminar, which examinedthe impact of WWII on the Soviet Union and surrounding regions, as well as aspects of the Soviet system from Stalin up to the 1980s.
As part of the International Partners Week, a ceremony of setting up Ca' Foscari University Information Corner at HSE University took place on June 19.
On June 18, the third International Partners’ Week ‘Academic Agility: Preparing Students for an Uncertain Future’ began at HSE University. The event brings together representatives of more than 30 universities from 16 countries, including France, Italy, Germany, the Netherlands, Turkey, the USA, Finland, the United Kingdom, and China. They have all come to Moscow to learn more about the kind of learning experience HSE University can provide, as well as to discuss practical challenges and solutions regarding international mobility.
This May, HSE and the Science and Technology Policy Institute (STEPI, Republic of Korea) signed a cooperation agreement on science and advanced technology research. This agreement was signed by Leonid Gokhberg, HSE First Vice Rector, Director of the Institute for Statistical Studies and Economics of Knowledge, and Dr. Hwang-Hee Cho, STEPI President.