Lockdown by Algorithm: A Proposed Model Calculates Optimal Restriction Levels
During the pandemic, countries have endeavoured to protect their citizens without hurting their economies with excessive restrictions. At the seminar ‘Living with Covid-19: Optimal Lockdown Policies’, Hubert Kempf, academic supervisor of HSE University’s International Laboratory for Macroeconomic Analysis, presented a mathematical model that can be used to calculate the optimal level of restrictions.
In 2020, many governments had to decide how to deal with the coronavirus pandemic, and the measures adopted varied greatly, depending on the severity of the epidemic in a particular country, its geographical location, the strength of its links to neighbouring countries, the political regime, and the views of the leadership. The severity of these measures ranged from complete lockdown, the halting of certain businesses, the closure of shops and cafes, and travel bans, to monitoring the situation without any restrictions.
Proponents of both extremes argue in favour of their preferred solution. Those who think it is appropriate to introduce a lockdown justify it on the basis of the need to contain the spread of the virus and to prevent the number of sick people from overwhelming hospital capacity. Those who oppose the restrictions point to the damage to the economy: entire industries (e.g., tourism and air travel) and many small- and medium-sized enterprises, which find it more difficult to survive a work stoppage than large ones, will suffer from a lockdown. In the first case, more people will be able to receive quality medical care and the death rate will be lower; in the second case, high unemployment will be avoided, and the severity of the economic crisis will be reduced.
Most countries have chosen policies that fall between these extremes. ‘Life during the coronavirus pandemic is a balancing act between the health benefits of lockdown and social distancing, and the economic and political costs of restrictions,’ said Hubert Kempf. But how can the severity of restrictions be calculated so that both public health and the economy suffer as little damage as possible? What are the parameters that determine economic damage and mortality rates?
It is not easy to generate a robust mathematical model, as the key factor (spread of infection) is not economic in nature and operates according to different laws. In addition, this pandemic represents the first time the global community has reacted in this way (never before have governments imposed such sweeping restrictions to save lives) and there is nothing to compare its evolution with. Several papers have been published on the course of Covid and the results of restrictive measures in different countries, but they do not offer mechanisms to guide decision-making processes.
Hubert Kempf and his co-author, Stéphane Rossignol of the University of Paris VIII, based their algorithm on the simple SIR model proposed by William Kermack and Anderson McKendrick in 1927. It divides the population into three groups: those who are susceptible, those who are infected, and those who have recovered. The model describes infection rates in a simplified way (a visualisation of the SIR model was made in the Washington Post).
Using existing work, the scientists created a mathematical model that takes into account the prevalence rate, R0 (the average number of people infected by one person who is sick), mortality (the proportion of those who become infected who die from the disease) and patient recovery. In addition, health system capacity (the number of people who can be treated at the same time) and the date at which a vaccine becomes available can be entered. The model calculates the duration of the pandemic, the damage to the economy, and the likely number of deaths associated with various levels of restrictions.
A key variable in the calculations is what the authors define as the ‘economic value of life'
This variable is assigned different values by different governments and determines the weighting with which the total number of deaths caused by the virus is included in the final equation. The equation itself allows for the calculation of an acceptable prevalence rate, and subsequently how stringent the required measures need to be to keep it at that level. In general, the higher a government values human life, the stricter the measures it takes should be, but for some ‘value of life’ ranges, the optimal level of restriction remains constant.
‘This work is theoretical; we are not trying to decide which policy would be right for Russia, for example,’ Professor Kempf said. ‘We want to understand how theoretically to justify mitigation policies.’
The International Laboratory for Macroeconomic Analysis was established in 2006. Its main areas of research are fiscal and monetary policy, the political economy of economic growth, and econometric methods of macroeconomic analysis and forecasting. Current laboratory projects include ‘Sustainable Public Finance’, ‘Information and Macroeconomic Policy’, ‘Problems in Empirical Macroeconomics and Macroeconomic Forecasting’ and ‘Political Economy of Growth and Development’. Twice a month the laboratory hosts an open research seminar. It is chaired by the Dean of the Faculty of Economic Sciences Professor Sergey Pekarski, and supervised by Professor Hubert Kempf (who is also Professor of Economics at the Ecole Normale Supérieure Paris-Saclay).
In an open talk organized for HSE – St. Petersburg undergraduate and graduate students, Cartier CEO Cyrille Vigneron spoke about the role of the modern luxury industry in various spheres of public life including business, art, science, and education, as well as how modern management employs methods of quantum physics.
The HSE eLearning Office will participate in the international Coursera Conference. The event, hosted by Coursera, HSE's strategic partner in the global distance learning market, will take place from April 19 to 21. Ekaterina Zinkovskaya of HSE’s eLearning Office talks about the conference and what positions HSE holds in the field of distance education.
HSE University researchers have identified the genes that play a crucial role in breast cancer metastasis. The results of the study were published in the journal PLOS ONE.
To improve its global competitiveness, Russia needs an independent environmental agenda along with a concept for environmental protection, and it makes sense to suggest a ‘global clean deal’ to Europe. A report outlining this, prepared by a team of experts from HSE University, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and environmentalists, was presented at TASS.
The Human Capital Multidisciplinary Research Centre will organize a series of presentations and roundtable discussions as part of theXXII HSE April Conference, which will take place from April 13 to 30, 2021.
HSE and Sberbank Will Host the April International Academic Conference on Economic and Social Development
From April 13 – 30, 2021, the XXII April International Academic Conference on Economic and Social Development (AIAC) will be held in Moscow. For the first time, the conference will be co-organized by HSE University and Sberbank.
In celebration of Russia’s Year of Science and Technology, we continue our series about HSE University’s international laboratories, which are headed by world-class scientists and scholars. The first of these, the Laboratory of Algebraic Geometry and Its Applications, was established in October 2010. Below, Laboratory Head Dmitry Kaledin discusses the Lab’s history, research, achievements, and current activities.
The collective volume Place and Nature: Essays in Russian Environmental History, co-edited by David Moon, Nicholas B. Breyfogle, and HSE researcher Alexandra Bekasova, was recently presented at a seminar of the Laboratory for the Environmental and Technological History of the Centre for Historical Research at HSE – St. Petersburg. The book is one of the fruits of a networking project carried out in 2013-2016 with active participation of HSE researchers.
The research and development of new approaches to antitrust regulation in the digital sector, the agro-industrial sector, the pharmaceutical industry, and other markets remain the main focus of the work of the BRICS Competition Law and Policy Centre, which operates within HSE University. The Centre's Supervisory Board recently endorsed its work conducted over the past year and supported its agenda for this year.
On March 28-31, 2021, the HSE International Laboratory ‘Russia’s Regions in Historical Perspective’ held an international conference ‘The Russian Far East: Regional and Transnational Perspectives (19th -21st cent.)’. The event was jointly organized by the Laboratory with the German Historical Institute Moscow, Indiana University Bloomington (USA), and the Institute of History, Archeology and Ethnography of the Peoples of the Far East FEB RAS (Vladivostok).