• A
  • A
  • A
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
Regular version of the site

‘Idea of Environmental Protection Should Become Part of Foreign Policy’

‘Idea of Environmental Protection Should Become Part of Foreign Policy’

© iStock

To improve its global competitiveness, Russia needs an independent environmental agenda along with a concept for environmental protection, and it makes sense to suggest a ‘global clean deal’ to Europe. A report outlining this, prepared by a team of experts from HSE University, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and environmentalists, was presented at TASS.

Until recently, environmental protection seemed like an ‘opportunist’ movement, and the ‘green’ agenda was viewed as ‘hostile’ in official documents, said Sergey Karaganov, Dean of the HSE Faculty of World Economy and International Affairs, as he presented the report ‘The Turn to Nature: The New Ecological Policy of Russian during the ‘Green’ Transformation of the World Economy and Politics’ on April 12th, 2021 at TASS. He believes this policy will continue to be seen as hostile until the country elaborates its own environmental policy. The idea of protecting nature should be an integral part of foreign policy, although currently, Moscow poorly exploits this agenda and is failing to suggest its own ideas.

Sergey Karaganov
© Nikolay Galkin/ TASS

At the same time, Russia also needs an internal transformation of its environmental policy. Today, protective measures are not part of one overall concept and are being poorly used to create a new agenda, one which could create a new patriotic idea bringing together people with different views.

Igor Makarov, Head of the HSE School of World Economy and one of the key authors of the report, believes that environmental protection is rapidly becoming the most important issue in the 21st century. The main topic of the report is Russia’s future position in a world where the green agenda will play a key role. Lagging behind in terms of development and implementation would mean new problems and threats.

We are not suggesting universal policies, but we hope to launch a discussion on the search for Russia’s position in the new ‘green’ world, in the international division of labour

An ecologically-oriented foreign policy is impossible without a corresponding internal one, and Russia will have to become a responsible ecological state, Igor Makarov believes. The reason for many global problems is unlimited consumption, and without changing this model in rich countries, it is impossible to solve environmental issues. The environmental agenda should be linked to the social one, with additional taxes implemented for those who consume excessive amounts of natural resources.

Igor Makarov said that the environmental policy should become a method of diversifying the economy, so that Russia can thrive in a world that is aiming to decrease the consumption of fossil fuels. The resource economy can help develop Siberia and the Far East, but should become more innovative and technologically advanced. Natural resource management should be based on human capital development.

To launch its turn towards nature, Russia’s environmental policy must be based on transparent ecological information; it should openly talk about problems and possible solutions. According to Igor Makarov, this will involve expert support that is both qualified and impartial. Wider state policy, including social and fiscal, will also be seen from the perspective of environmental policy.

The environmental agenda will be the cornerstone of future state policy

Dmitry Suslov, Deputy Director of the HSE Centre for Comprehensive European and International Studies (CCEIS), believes that Russia’s environmental agenda should be different from the Western one and emphasize Russia’s contribution to the solution of the global ecological problems; it is capable of reinforcing the country’s status in the global arena, and should not be limited solely to the problems of climate and global warming. It should be focused on fairness, Dmitry Suslov believes, unlike the Western approach, which blames carbon-intensive manufacturers for climate change. At the same time, carbon-intensive product manufacturers and consumers in the West should equally pay for emissions.

Dmitry Suslov called the current EU’s ‘green’ policy a tool of competition rather than a method to decrease emissions. The European Union has made considerably advancements in this matter and is now looking to make other countries pay the EU. Russia should insist on a fairer green agenda, but this agenda should be promoted not by the country alone, but together with its BRICS and SCO partners.

© iStock

He believes that Russia should offer the EU a ‘global clean deal’,  and in particular, count EU countries’ investment in clean technologies in other countries as a contribution to carbon neutrality. Russia can also suggest initiatives to organize the production of power hydrogen and its delivery to Europe. Brussels will most probably refuse, but Moscow should suggest it nevertheless, seizing the environmental agenda and putting the EU in a defensive position. As a result, Dmitry Suslov believes, it will be harder to introduce carbon fees.

At the same time, dialogue with the U.S. should be intensified on environmental protection, particularly in the Arctic, where the climate is warming is three times faster than the global average, and to slow down confrontation between the two countries. The expert believes that environmental challenges for Russia are both a risk and an opportunity at the same time.

If we look at ecology as something of secondary importance, the country will face economic stagnation, growing risks in health care, and a worsening living environment

Such a scenario would also lead to failures in foreign policy

Alexei Drobinin, Acting Director of the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs Foreign Policy Planning Department, agrees that the problems of environmental protection and climate change are gaining foreign policy and geopolitical aspects. It is necessary to have a set of scenarios and recommendations for decision-making in the near future and for the medium-term. He mentioned the need to involve experts in preparing foreign policy decisions. Mr. Drobinin believes that the Russian environmental policy should be based on the national interest, while international experience should be considered at the same time.

Igor Bashmakov, Executive Director of the Centre for Effective Energy Use, believes that to reduce pollution, it is necessary not to limit consumption, but instead to promote a rational approach. The key method for this, he believes, is the development of new technologies, rather than altering behaviours.

Russia has been developing very slowly on a raw-material model over the last years, Mr. Bashmakov concluded, and the country hasn’t managed to accelerate its growth by means of energy resources. It is essential to look for new drivers of growth, and green technologies may provide a solution. Investment in the low-carbon economy improves the pace of development, and the return on such investments is much higher than on investment in the resource-based economy. It is important that the green agenda is brought to the foreground and stops being a decoration that is not considered important, Igor Bashmakov said.

The return on investment in decreasing emissions in Russia will be high. According to experts’ calculations, an energy-effective overhaul in, for example, Kemerovo, will return a significantly bigger effect than anywhere else in Europe. ‘Russia’s symbol should be the birch, not a blast furnace or coal-fired power station’, Igor Bashmakov concluded.

Sergey Karaganov completed the discussion and mentioned that any environmental policy should work for Russia’s interests. For a country such as  Russia with its huge natural riches, environmental protection should be part of a bigger concept, which is able to bring together people of different views.

See also:

When Risks Are Too High: The International Centre of Decision Choice and Analysis on the Outcomes of Its Work

In the more than 10 years since it was established, the HSE International Centre of Decision Choice and Analysis has travelled a long way from a laboratory to an academic centre of gravity for globally renowned scholars.Fuad Aleskerov, Professor in the HSE Faculty of Economic Sciences and Director of the HSE International Centre of Decision Choice and Analysis, spoke about the evolution of the centre’s team, its research activity, and solving Arctic dilemmas through the use of mathematical models.

HSE to Support the 2022 International Mind Games

An intellectual competition for secondary school students from all over the world who are lovers of science and technology will be held in Yakutia with the participation of HSE University. High school students from all over the world will gather for several days to participate in projects in the natural sciences and humanities led by scientists and scholars from around the world.

Cartier CEO Delivers a Public Lecture to HSE – St. Petersburg Students

In an open talk organized for HSE – St. Petersburg undergraduate and graduate students, Cartier CEO Cyrille Vigneron spoke about the role of the modern luxury industry in various spheres of public life including business, art, science, and education, as well as how modern management employs methods of quantum physics.

World Bank Forecasts a Rise in Poverty

General wealth levels in Eastern Europe and Central Asia have been improving since 2012 — poverty has been decreasing. But due to COVID, global poverty levels, including those of these regions, may increase considerably for the first time in two decades. Samuel Freije-Rodriguez, Lead Economist at World Bank, talked about this at the XXII April Conference organized by HSE University and Sberbank.

Platform of Evolution: Education Systems in the Post-COVID World

The HSE eLearning Office will participate in the international Coursera Conference. The event, hosted by Coursera, HSE's strategic partner in the global distance learning market, will take place from April 19 to 21. Ekaterina Zinkovskaya of HSE’s eLearning Office talks about the conference and what positions HSE holds in the field of distance education.

HSE April International Participants Conference to Discuss Global and National Challenges

The Human Capital Multidisciplinary Research Centre will organize a series of presentations and roundtable discussions as part of theXXII HSE April Conference, which will take place from April 13 to 30, 2021.

HSE and Sberbank Will Host the April International Academic Conference on Economic and Social Development

From April 13 – 30, 2021, the XXII April International Academic Conference on Economic and Social Development (AIAC) will be held in Moscow. For the first time, the conference will be co-organized by HSE University and Sberbank.

Exploring the History of Places and Environment in Russia

The collective volume Place and Nature: Essays in Russian Environmental History, co-edited by David Moon, Nicholas B. Breyfogle, and HSE researcher Alexandra Bekasova, was recently presented at a seminar of the Laboratory for the Environmental and Technological History of the Centre for Historical Research at HSE – St. Petersburg. The book is one of the fruits of a networking project carried out in 2013-2016 with active participation of HSE researchers.

‘We have Formed a Unique Partnership Network of Some of the Strongest Think Tanks in the World’

The research and development of new approaches to antitrust regulation in the digital sector, the agro-industrial sector, the pharmaceutical industry, and other markets remain the main focus of the work of the BRICS Competition Law and Policy Centre, which operates within HSE University. The Centre's Supervisory Board recently endorsed its work conducted over the past year and supported its agenda for this year.

Conference Brings Together New Perspectives on the Russian Far East

On March 28-31, 2021, the HSE International Laboratory ‘Russia’s Regions in Historical Perspective’ held an international conference ‘The Russian Far East: Regional and Transnational Perspectives (19th -21st cent.)’. The event was jointly organized by the Laboratory with the German Historical Institute Moscow, Indiana University Bloomington (USA), and the Institute of History, Archeology and Ethnography of the Peoples of the Far East FEB RAS (Vladivostok).